Popular Post emy_rose Posted January 11, 2016 Popular Post Share Posted January 11, 2016 3 hours ago, carolinedl said: So I saw that @emy_rose answered one of the long TK/DS posts on the MT! Thank you! I hope you'll get an answer. I don't think she answers the posts she has no answer for, meaning the posts that challenge what she says. Hi chingu, first of all I want to say that I really am happy that you and so many people liked my posts Everyone, I appreciate your support... really But this will be my only post on this beautiful shipping paradise till next week because right now "I'm shipping the script"... yes I know please don't think that I'm out of my mind like someone we all know I'm just keeping my distance from the beautiful posts that I read here because I want to be "impartial" as much as possible for that narrow mind that is talking nonsense on the MT. But I really liked a lot that you pointed out that that person is not replying to my posts because that's really what I want... I want her to say that I'm a JH shipper and that I'm not impartial... I want to point out how arrogant she is when she insist that her strange theories are the only possible interpretation while hiding behind that writer shipping thing... since I'm liking R88 too that means that I'm liking the writers too, I'm just understanding things in my own way... Anyway it's really a pity that so many people are avoiding the MT because it's not a space where we can all love the writer's work freely anymore. This is the last week so I don't want to stay silent anymore and since I'm like JB I'll not stop till I'll get what I want... that person needs to admit that she is not omniscient 44 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 11, 2016 Share Posted January 11, 2016 These pictures look pretty R-rated to me credits: reply1988_ryu Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
honeywell Posted January 11, 2016 Share Posted January 11, 2016 27 minutes ago, vilavila said: So, a question for anyone who remembers reply '94 in response to a post in MT. Hide contents Someone noticed a bride and groom doll set in TK's room. Do you recall whether there was a similar bride and groom doll set in reply '94 and where was it? From what I remember there was. There were even 2 traditional marriage ducks at some point. For JH/DS there was the Japanese married couple that someone pointed out before. 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
raky Posted January 11, 2016 Share Posted January 11, 2016 Gud day chingus. Or Gud evening to some. haven't back track yet.. So not sure if this theory has been put in the table.. With regards to the prophecy.. That our 3 ommas' received from the fortune teller. Is it possible that she had a little bit of mixed up. JH and SW omma both asked the question simultaneously.. So fortune teller told them to ask one by one.. So, JH omma went first. Lady then told JH omma that her eldest would have a great fortune -by which the other two omma seconded by saying Oppa JB would maybe pass the waiting list. DS omma even said to JH omma... this lady even knows you have an older son. But then they also asked when is that happening.. The good fortune.. And lady said by end of lunar year? Not sure now what they call the other one (was it calendar year?) and the timeline in between is a mystery to me. DS omma added that maybe JB oppa might win another lottery. then lady also mentioned that second son would do well on his own ( not sure if SWs omma prediction came after or before saying this though.. Need to rewatch that part..) SW omma asked about her son getting into a university (was it yonsei or seoul.. Me not sure again. Lol.) and lady said she'll have a better fortune than that. DS omma mentioned DSs name, by which lady predicted was the reason of her failing little by little not getting into college. And so the name change. We learned by the mid hour what lady predicted with SW omma -that she'll be having another son. Later on... JH omma was furious with the lady fortune teller saying she's a fake coz JB oppa obviously didn't pass... Well Not until a few yrs after. And the probability of SW omma being pregnant with another child was close to nil that time. But then by the end of the epi.. We or me at the very least assumed that the 'son' she was predicted with of having is not a newborn but could possibly be 'Taek' himself. As we see Taek coming in with SW to eat with them. So.. That's the end of it!?? Maybe.. Maybe not. How so?! With the recent development on the last epi. There's a hint of a possible pregnancy with JH omma. (A menopause is feasible but I would think that she's still too young for that to happen u know) and IF and only IF this indeed happen -JH omma being pregnant... There's a high probability that lady fortune teller might have gotten her prediction mixed up between the two omma having 'two' sons. the 'older son' predicted to have a great fortune would have been SW.. He got into medical school with a full scholarship .. Now with regards to the timeline -whether it's within the lunar or calendar year that he got that news I'm not too sure of beCoz am not familiar with the Korean calendar to say the least. But having a full scholarship for med school for SW omma is almost like hitting a lottery jackpot, is it not? So I've come to a theory that the second son predicted as living fine on his own would be TaEk. Cozy technically.. He is SW ommas' second son by marriage or by association with TaEks appa, no? (Am I being too biased here. Lol. ) not sure whose older by age.. SW or TaEk.. But regardless.. I would still think that SW is older.. Even if it's just beCoz he is the first son in her family.. (Still me being biased.. Lol.) sooo.. There's goes my delusional theory. Not sure which one I'll be more embarrassed to admit -me driving for over an hour to work thinking of R1988 storylines the whole time.. Or me getting it all wrong with this theory. Hee. Later chingus. 4 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Popular Post Richi07 Posted January 11, 2016 Popular Post Share Posted January 11, 2016 Chingu i just want to ask, why DS always wearing skirt when she was with JH? ( except when she pretending to dislocate in LMS concert 1989) i remember she wearing skirt : - when she going to mbc concert with JH - when she going to apgujung with her friend, and then JH come along at McD - when she going to JH birthday party - when she going with all the ssangmundong gang - and last, when JH farewell in ep. 18 at my opinion because I'm a girl, i always wearing skirt when i really want to look pretty and when with someone special to get my crush attention . Or it's just me to feel this is a clue/hint to person who DS like 58 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Popular Post wasted_youth Posted January 11, 2016 Popular Post Share Posted January 11, 2016 The only thing I know is, Shin ajusshi won't let this full and sexy lips go to waste. He has probably told both JY and HR to get ready for that ONE AND ONLY KISS. "Yideura, we're going to make the kiss look like the one between Jung Kyung-ho and Nam Gyu-ri in Cruel City with tongue action and all that. So be prepared, watch a lot of yeong-a movies and practice with your mirror. Hyeri-yang, if you need a more specific example, just google Yoon Eun-Hye sshi Cola Kisseu." Practice, Junyeora, don't just sit there imagining and blushing. YE!! GAMDOG-NIM! #EONAMRYU #LIPSDONTLIE 54 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Eessttaa Posted January 11, 2016 Share Posted January 11, 2016 Believing on cover CD REPLY 1988 part 2 that will be released on 01.15.2016 why??u know why cingu,LOL 11 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest wizengamot Posted January 11, 2016 Share Posted January 11, 2016 ok, you know i've been coming to MT lately, at the latest page someone pointed out that sympathy for JH is unfair to TK because TK also is suffering and has stepped back for JH. And she/he even said that how much it must have hurt TK when he found out that DS got stood up on the concert so he run all the way for her, not caring about his match or career. My simple question that always baffles me though is... Why can TK cancel a match but not confess to DS for six years? If he is so willingly be the the talk of the town and/or the baduk world because of cancelling a match that is very unlike him, that even his family and neighbors would heard of on the radio, why then can he not confess in those six years? Anyway, my simple answer to why people are focusing on JH is because he's the one who bear his heart out. Yes, JH and TK suffer. But no, I'm not going to take pity on JH for suffering because he brought it upon himself. He could have confessed but he didn't and the same goes for TK (he didn't confess), it's not like they don't have a choice. They could confess and possibly lose the friendship or stay quiet and keep the friendship. It's both hard but the point is: They have a choice. You can't tell me they don;t have a choice. But because after all this time, JH finally spoke and wear his heart on his sleeve. He peeled something of himself. He took off the tough facade and that is why people are focusing on JH. @ricenamja thanks heh Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Aya Hong Posted January 11, 2016 Share Posted January 11, 2016 2 hours ago, EMM! said: I hope everyone is coping up easily~ Seriously.. this thread is so lovely.. I got over my pain and now I'm laughing and feeling light as I read through our thread, and even in the MT. (we don't even talk about the kiss scene anymore???? hahahahaha the confession scene broke us all XD) We'll have to repeat what we did for the past two days yet again once the subs are out in a few hours. I'm sorry for reminding you about it. And for those who are feeling like they're losing hope, and felt like they were cheated and should've gone the other way.. Try to think hard as you can as to why you believed Junghwan is Deoksun's husband, don't even try to hunt for clues, for symbolisms, for parallelisms-- think about it yourself using your own capabilities and guts and wits-- you'll understand why you even shipped them in the first place. It's not yet the end, but we all have to deal with this ending, so if ever fate and timing and destiny are not on our side, let's keep our cool and think about the fun memories we had on this thread! AIGOOOO CHAM IT'S LIKE I'M SAYING GOODBYE TO EVERYONE ASKDJALSDKJA T_T I can't help but feel emo.. Today is the last Monday we'll ever wonder who Deoksun's husband would be. We will never give up till the end because when we are talking about clues, both can fit in to be the husband so we stay positive e and that's right we will enjoy this, if it will break out heart at least we knew that somewhere out there, there are persons like JH and DS. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
carolinedl Posted January 11, 2016 Share Posted January 11, 2016 7 minutes ago, emy_rose said: Hi chingu, first of all I want to say that I really am happy that you and so many people liked my posts Everyone, I appreciate your support... really But this will be my only post on this beautiful shipping paradise till next week because right now "I'm shipping the script"... yes I know please don't think that I'm out of my mind like someone we all know I'm just keeping my distance from the beautiful posts that I read here because I want to be "impartial" as much as possible for that narrow mind that is talking nonsense on the MT. But I really liked a lot that you pointed out that that person is not replying to my posts because that's really what I want... I want her to say that I'm a JH shipper and that I'm not impartial... I want to point out how arrogant she is when she insist that her strange theories are the only possible interpretation while hiding behind that writer shipping thing... since I'm liking R88 too that means that I'm liking the writers too, I'm just understanding things in my own way... Anyway it's really a pity that so many people are avoiding the MT because it's not a space where we can all love the writer's work freely anymore. This is the last week so I don't want to stay silent anymore and since I'm like JB I'll not stop till I'll get what I want... that person needs to admit that she is not omniscient Yeah, I understand the impartial part. We'll see you in the MT anyway I hope you'll get an answer and we'll support you if things start to get heated! I wish she would have answered my post. When she accused me of being blind, I actually clarified what I meant, other TK/DS got it, and no answer from her. Then the previous episode actually proved that she was wrong (She had said that Taek had loved DS first, though we have seen that JH has liked DS from a while back!) and still nothing... I don't think she will ever answer since her argument of then has been destroyed. 20 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
lala14 Posted January 11, 2016 Share Posted January 11, 2016 15 hours ago, ricenamja said: These pictures look pretty R-rated to me STOP MAKING ME THINKING PERVY THINGS ABOUT HIM PLZ... Btw, can anyone teach me how to remove picts in quote? Edit: thanks @wizengamot 10 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ladywhise Posted January 11, 2016 Share Posted January 11, 2016 4 hours ago, mojobobo said: I believe it's this song Yup its this song, thank you so much! 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest wizengamot Posted January 11, 2016 Share Posted January 11, 2016 @carolinedl @emy_rose she only answers those who praise her (and follow her lol. she mentioned why the TK shippers are following her everywhere. she must have like that) so she's only answering the TK shippers or any neutral who would ask her. But i don't think she will answer any JH-DS shipper. Even though you say you're not a DS-JH shipper, i bet she still thinks you are. I'm just super glad now that she finally admitted that she thinks it's TK. Coz really, it is so frustrating to have her be all i-m-neutral-and-is-shipping-the-script then misinterpret, over analyze, read too much of the actions and dialogues in a way that it will point to TK. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
mojobobo Posted January 11, 2016 Share Posted January 11, 2016 11 minutes ago, Richi07 said: Chingu i just want to ask, why DS always wearing skirt when she was with JH? ( except when she pretending to dislocate in LMS concert 1989) i remember she wearing skirt : - when she going to mbc concert with JH - when she going to apgujung with her friend, and then JH come along at McD - when she going to JH birthday party - when she going with all the ssangmundong gang - and last, when JH farewell in ep. 18 at my opinion because I'm a girl, i always wearing skirt when i really want to look pretty and when with someone special to get my crush attention . Or it's just me to feel this is a clue/hint to person who DS like On this point even when DS was going to meet her date for the movie (and she and JH missed each other) she was wearing pants and not skirt hehehe 15 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest wizengamot Posted January 11, 2016 Share Posted January 11, 2016 5 minutes ago, lala14 said: STOP MAKING ME THINKING PERVY THINGS ABOUT HIM PLZ... Btw, can anyone teach me how to remove picts in quote? go to edit then highlight the pics then press delete or back space. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
jungdeok88 Posted January 11, 2016 Share Posted January 11, 2016 5 hours ago, laurahandayani said: I was really worried after watching ep. 17. That damn kiss scene really gets me. Seems like the writers want us to guess if it is a dream or not. But honestly I think it doesn't really matter. Even if it did happen, the fact that DS acts like nothing happened is an answer to TK. She loves JH. Of course I want JH to be her first kiss, but reply series is portraying reality. Not all first kiss means true love/the last love. I hope I don't offend anyone, but I feel like the kiss scene is stuffed in there to fulfill DS x TK shippers' thirst. (and more epic victory for us ) Yes, TK is definitely an attractive character and he is definitely popular. But I don't think Reply 1988 writers would change the script just because of his popularity. After watching ep. 18, I felt somehow relieved. I think someone mentioned before that something must have happened after the concert between DS x TK. I concur! I think that the reason she keeps looking to her pager and the door is because TK finally confessed but DS doesn't feel the same and she feels bad. I LOVE JH's confession scene. That was DAEBAK! DS's smile is like saying, "FINALLY, I KNEW IT! What took you so long to confess, JH.." LOLOL I mean look at his eyes. DS definitely knows he's dead serious. Can't wait for the last 2 episodes, chingu!!! this is what i really need!!! thank you for your great analysis of DS's behaviour which got me felt so restless bcs i kept thinking it was her showing not so subtly about her developed (from friend to special one) feeling towards Taek. but then i realized that nothing happened between DS and TK in time 1989-1994 by read their usual deeds to each other. So i can be pretty sure that DS don't love Taek nor consider him as man like her crush to SW or her feeling to JH back then (and now). the writernim is indeed so witty in making plot to direct the audience to not-the-actual-meanings of so many scenes in this drama a.k.a guessing-game-like. i pray hard for DS's feeling for Taek is mere guilty and not love!! please i just can't stand seeing JH so heartbroken with his bitter smile when he stared DS and noticing she's waiting for Taek. 5 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ladywhise Posted January 11, 2016 Share Posted January 11, 2016 I do not know if anyone have noticed this during the montage when JH asked NH to give his gift to DS, did anyone notice the GREEN Ribbon? This reminds me of the color theories. I read about this not too long ago from the MT COLOR THEORIES 5 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
fictionista Posted January 11, 2016 Share Posted January 11, 2016 Okay so this is unrelated to JH-DS but I was wondering how you guys interpreted that scene in ep 17 between Taek and JH at the soccer field. That is when JH asks Taek if he opened his wallet, and he replied with a perfectly clueless expression that he didn't. I love Taek as a character very much but didn't any of you feel he was being a little too crafty in that scene? The very fact that JH brought up the topic of the wallet indicates that he was willing to have a heart-to-heart conversation with Tk regarding DS and yet Taek diplomatically avoided it. My question is why? To spare JH the awkwardness or because of his latent desire to let JH keep playing the noble idiot till the end? Why not instead opt for the simple solution of confessing to DS and find out whom she accepts? My guess is Taek is a little unsure of whether DS will accept his proposal at all and this is why he purposely steered clear of any discussion. Maybe he himself believes that chances of DS accepting JH are way higher than accepting him? Obviously I'm not trying to bring down Taek's greatness as a character just questioning what the implication of this scene could be. What do you guys think? 16 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
yours19 Posted January 11, 2016 Share Posted January 11, 2016 16 minutes ago, Richi07 said: Chingu i just want to ask, why DS always wearing skirt when she was with JH? ( except when she pretending to dislocate in LMS concert 1989) i remember she wearing skirt : - when she going to mbc concert with JH - when she going to apgujung with her friend, and then JH come along at McD - when she going to JH birthday party - when she going with all the ssangmundong gang - and last, when JH farewell in ep. 18 at my opinion because I'm a girl, i always wearing skirt when i really want to look pretty and when with someone special to get my crush attention . Or it's just me to feel this is a clue/hint to person who DS like yeah, i think that too. and remember SW once said that BR only wearing skirt when she meet her boyfriend. and BR is DS sister after all... so maybe in this thing, BR and DS is look a like at each other. 6 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Popular Post MrsSoJiSub Posted January 11, 2016 Popular Post Share Posted January 11, 2016 Do you people never sleep? *says the girl who is almost always here LOL* This is what my flat mate told me while I was freaking out about this show: Why are you being such an idiot? You said he confessed right? *nod my head vigorously* Then there it is. It doesn't matter if she's dating the other dude or what not. He confessed. Even if she likes him or not, dating the other dude or not; that confession is going to be on her mind. She is going have to reevaluate things, think on things, and come to some sort of conclusion. In real life a guy confesses to you, even when your married, you have a moment of thinking. Why does this guy like me? What signals have I been putting out? He has been putting in that I obviously missed? Look she's going to think back on moments and ask herself if it's true and why she never saw or did see it. She's going to want to know why he's confessing now. Oh my gosh girl there are probably so many thoughts and emotions running through that girls head. Wait you said they sort of had a thing in high school right? *nods again* *laughing her richard simmons off* You are a trip girl, he's the husband. *I am about to say something about Taek* Girl, it don't matter he's the husband. Calm your richard simmons. You been watching this show and since day one you been say he's the husband. Even if she went to the concert with other dude, did that one dude see it? He rushed to be there, missed by a moment, but he saw it right? *nods head* He's the husband. It's basic storytelling 101. They are putting him through the ringer so you feel more for him and are even more desperate for him to get the girl. Think of every rom-com ever....he's the husband. At this point you are just waiting for her to let down the other dude and for her to confess to her dude. Girl, there is a reason they been showing you her reactions to one and not so much of the other. He's the husband. I don't even have to really pay attention to the show to know he's the husband. You and I are no longer going to talk about this because he is the husband. Also you are making me curious to start paying attention when you force me to watch and I am not turning into you. He's the husband, bye. I am so happy I may be able to turn my flat mate into a kdrama addict "yessss come to the dark side" once I rope her in she is never going to want to leave LOL. Junghwan is the husband. I went back and thought on everything from the very beginning and he's it. Someone here said it using comparison of the other two series themes of fate and destiny and I can't find that long post but I agree and I said basically the same on the main thread in the beginning. People were going on about fate and destiny and I said it comes down to choice, to Deok Sun's choice and that is exactly what we are seeing now. We were given the same messages with Tae Woon and Chilbong. The message being (sorry former Chilbong lovers) you can be the perfect guy. Buy the perfect gift. Say the perfect words. Have time always on your side and confess on someone's D-Day, make it to Y2K, and arrive at the concert venue first. But if the girl doesn't like you. She just doesn't feel the same way for you. You're perfect everything just doesn't compare in her eyes and heart to the other ones imperfect. Before anyone comes down on me, yes the girl appreciates it. Yes she's thankful. Yes she knows that you are an awesome guy that any girl or boy would be lucky to have in their life. Unfortunately you're just not her guy. I think the drama does this really well by showing gifts. In AM 97, both bothers gift Shiwon a the exact same ring (it killed me that it was the same one also with this one it was so obvious who she was going to chose given the flashback of what she says, when she says she wanted a ring for her birthday and then asking it from Yoonjae the next year. Yoonjae even says as much in his confession). We see that one ring gets left in the bathroom and the other adores her finger. The perfect gift comes down to something forgotten because it's not always about the gift but the one who gives it to you. In AM 94 both Chilbong and Oppa got to Japan. Both are asked to bring back something. Chilbong brings back the perfect expensive Chanel #5 perfume that makes Jeong's eyes shine. Oppa gets her a make up kit with the worst color palette known to man. But then we see he also got her comic books and marshmallows she's been asking for. Now let's compare, Chanel #5 perfume is hella expensive and I'm thinking more so then and from a Duty Fee store too. Comparing that to comic and marshmallows, the latter seems like nothing. However those two gifts had a lot of meaning and background to it (the comic is the one Jeong wanted to read but oppa had loaned it to a friend and she had told him "you're no help to my life", the marshmallows were her precious ones that could only be found in Japan. She had been saving to eat that and oppa had eaten it. Jeong wanted to kill him or the person who ate it, for it). Jeong uses the Chanel perfume and we are shown (even in episodes that are months later, but I need to check to be sure, sure) she hasn't opened the marshmallows. It is tucked away in her drawer (not sure if the comics were there or not). To her those two gifts (three because she never used the make either but for different reason I believe LOL) are more precious than anything Chilbong could bring (ducks from former shippers) because it's not really the gift but who brings it that adds more value and meaning. We get gift giving messages in this drama too (and I believe that is why a big deal was made about the pink shirt in the MT). The two pink gloves. Come on, anyone who thinks it's a positive thing that she chose to wear Taek's mittens (oh the difference between the two are significant) but we have yet to see her wear or even seen the pink gloves Junghwan gifted her....there is a bridge in Brooklyn I want to sell you. Her not wearing the gloves is the same as Jeong not eating the marshmallows. It will be such a missed opportunity by the writer if we don't see those pink gloves (and pink shirt) again before the drama ends. Then we have Taek who gives her that prized and treasured trophy he won. The amount of sleepless nights and practice we saw Taek put into winning that trophy. It's a huge deal and it still warms my heart that he gave it to her (just cause I don't ship doesn't mean I can't appreciate good things when I see it). Yet that precious trophy, was used as a kimchi pot. The first gift that Taek gives Deok Sun freely and willingly all on his own, by his own accord, and thinking, and actions (the mittens don't count, count because it was secret santa and he was required to get her something. Also she went through great pains -even failing- to let him know that pink gloves is what she wants -and it was still wrong-. It counts with Junghwan because he didn't have to get the gloves -and look at the parallel just as she didn't have to get him a birthday gift because the group gifts one together- since he wasn't her secret Santa. Also he came to the conclusion of the perfect pink gloves all on his own. Can the show be more obvious) becomes a kimchi pot *cue the goat sound* If Taek is the husband, imam need a flashback of her getting him a personal birthday gift in 1994. I am going to need to see that trophy proudly on display in her bedroom or apartment or somewhere. I kind of feel like kicking my own richard simmons for even allowing the internet to make me doubt, because the show does little and big things episode by episode to show you the clear cut answer. It is only once we start digging too deep into things (who cares who reads comics, what hand the person was using, the jacket they were wearing, bowing or not) these things can be explained away by the writers all too easily. But some things, the message of their story, the foundations they have established and keep progressing at; that's going to take a hell of a lot of explanations. Again, I can't provide you guys with pictures and minute detail analysis of a blink, a sneeze, eye contact, or shoe tie (and frankly, I don't want to LOL) but it's there. When I think on things of each episode, it's there and going to one conclusion. Junghwan is the husband. I'm going to leave that deep analysis to @blue_angel_1004 who says she's making one, but it's there ya'll. It's been there from the very first episode till now. *sorry for another long post and please excuse grammar and such which I will fix later. 64 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now