[Official] Ryu Jun Yeol ❤ Hyeri Official Thread (Junghwan & Deoksun of Reply 1988)

[odiaz]

whoaa this thread move soo fast.

we have a very huge ship here  virtual hugs for all of you guys!!!

i was watching some mv about uri couple in youtube and suddenly thankful that JH never kissed DS(or they just didn't show us yet? but i hope he never kissed DS). i just find it very sweet how he loves her innocently. like, it doesnt have to be a kiss or hug or any skinship, just being around her already make him beyond happy. 

 

[honeywell]

The kiss definitely needs to be addressed and what DS was feeling.   Watching episode 17 now with subs and I can see the other shippers side. They can really make a good argument with this episode.

[cheetah88]

2 hours ago, kandyrn said:

 Also, I find it interesting how JH has their picture always with him by keeping it in his wallet and CT which is the one to constantly travel and doesn't see the girl every day has his in his save keeping drawer. Shouldn't he (the one to see the girl less) want to keep their picture with him at all times?

Thisss! im so agree with this! 

why taek only keep the photo on his desk? while JH who can see her everyday always bring the photo inside his wallet. Just like he said, even he alrdy see DS a dozen times, he still want to see her more (OH MY HEARTTTT!!) 

 

ps: i keep watching the confession scene before going to sleep, hope i can watch what will happen next in my dreams! LOL! 

[parkangel]

4 hours ago, Asha Mizuki said:

@wizengamot  i need some negativity for a well-balanced life : I cackled 

My reaction after reading her post: Dang you writer-nim for emphasising on JH's insignificant umbrella scene by showing it again in ep.18. Why can't you follow your own script? 

Lol... Writer nim must so confused. 

I am very sorry, but I think she needs to know that the unimportant umbrella scene is also shown in the Reply 1988 official calendar, along with bus scene. While they just put 1 picture of DS TK.

[einYoshiChan]

43 minutes ago, odiaz said:

whoaa this thread move soo fast.

we have a very huge ship here  virtual hugs for all of you guys!!!

 

i was watching some mv about uri couple in youtube and suddenly thankful that JH never kissed DS(or they just didn't show us yet? but i hope he never kissed DS). i just find it very sweet how he loves her innocently. like, it doesnt have to be a kiss or hug or any skinship, just being around her already make him beyond happy. 

 

exactly !! his love is so pure,not because of lust after "alley scene' like other shippers mention before,not because she hugs him when her mother chased her and not because she act cute at "meow scene"..he just love her because she is SUNG DEOKSUN.. he still in love with her even after 6 years they separated,he still remember every single things they did at the past,and i know this guy will continue love her deeply even after his hair all become white..

[vilavila]

30 minutes ago, Chizawa95 said:

[+1,164, -28] While watching this, I was so satisfied watching Yoojung sunbae do something in 3 episodes that Jungpal still hasn't been able to do in 18 episodes... totally made up for the frustration I felt all weekend ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[+1,197, -24] Junghwan-ah... learn from this ㅜㅜ

Knetz so frustration with Reply i think.. even they are still mention Junghwan from the other drama article.. I think Knetz in Team Junghwan.. same like the way they support Trash in R94. When R94 ongoing.. from the beginning Knetz also mention that The Husband is Trash. I backread again all knetz comment.. so i hope writternim dont change her mind because knetz also mention Junghwan is the husband from earlier ep. 

Ok. Time to go watch Yoo Jung did on ep 3.

I was about to ask what the Koreans are thinking,  so thanks for sharing this post.

[Vannyah M]

Ok now i dont feel that well. One really have to be a masochist to watch this and endure the torturing. If you are weak hearted dont watch subbed 17 and 18 before finale.

[odiaz]

23 minutes ago, cheetah_omma said:

Thisss! im so agree with this! 

why taek only keep the photo on his desk? while JH who can see her everyday always bring the photo inside his wallet. Just like he said, even he alrdy see DS a dozen times, he still want to see her more (OH MY HEARTTTT!!) 

 

ps: i keep watching the confession scene before going to sleep, hope i can watch what will happen next in my dreams! LOL! 

isnt the photo of TK and DS in TK's journal? CMIIW. that means he brings it everywhere he goes too.

but yeah keeping it on your wallet makes it more intimate. i keep photos of my closest friends on my journal, but only my mother on my wallet

[artsycharisma]

11 minutes ago, odiaz said:

isnt the photo of TK and DS in TK's journal? CMIIW. that means he brings it everywhere he goes too.

but yeah keeping it on your wallet makes it more intimate. i keep photos of my closest friends on my journal, but only my mother on my wallet

 

From what I can tell from ep 13... TK keeps his journal in the drawer at all times (locked up). 

Please correct me if I'm wrong. 

[dairymilks]

3 minutes ago, artsycharisma said:

 

From what I can tell from ep 13... TK keeps his journal in the drawer at all times (locked up). 

Please correct me if I'm wrong. 

Yes, iirc, Junghwan found the journal and saw the pic, then put it back inside the drawer with the padlock. Which means, he doesn't carry it around all the time. 

[Kelly86]

1 hour ago, MrsSoJiSub said:

 It floors me because I wasn't even going to ship and wasn't feeling any of the ships in this drama (I said so on the main thread waaay back when. i knew who the husband was but i wasn't getting the feels feels for them) but I don't even know what episode it started, suddenly it became a need for me to have Deok Sun and Junghwan scene and no longer was he the husband but he had to be the husband because *fangirl, fangirl, fangirl* 

I swear when this drama ends I am billing the writers and PD for the emotional roller coaster they put up through and how they made up addicts to every word, gesture, look, burp, and shoe ties, these characters did/do.

 I totally agree, and can relate lol. When I first decided to jump on soompi again it was bc I was liking the drama and wanted to see what was going on here. At that point in time I was still neutral. I like PBG, & RJY the new actor was also getting my attention so it didn't matter to me who was the husband. Trust me I even commented in the TK/DS thread now I wouldn't go there.  

But ik the exact moment JH won me over. It was when TK confessed to the guys in 10 & RJY's awesome acting for JH in that scene stole my heart. That was my moment when my heart told me omg, look at his sad expression. I can't bare see those sad eyes anymore esp right after the SW misunderstanding too. He stole my heart with his puppy eyes...there was no turning back now I was no longer neutral so I dropped in HERE and never looked back at the TS/DS thread.

Ikr, darn writer and PD I have never ever in my life been so miserable OVER A DRAMA AND FICTIONAL CHARACTER. I use to be able to distinguish reality and "just a drama" but I feel like black magic was used on me with reply 88 I can't seem to shake off that it's just a DRAMA. On Sat, I was repeating in my room out loud "it's just a DRAMA, & not even my relationship" stop it, STOP it but nope the heartache & pain stayed.  learned my big lesson don't watch the next reply installment. It can ruin my happy life...or watch AFTER it's all out take the beating in one go if I have to! Delays = 10x the pain. 

[tituyphing]

On 1/10/2016 at 11:22 PM, pluie625 said:

 

@honeywell yeah exactly! I feel so too ever since I watched the live broadcast. Epi 17 dedicated to Taek, and many of it can be interpreted to support Taek. Beside the loveline I love epi 17, but everytime loveline scene appears my heart was uneasy by what the other ship would take on this. 

But then I told myself, 'why should you care about what they think, as long as your Junghwan is still the endgame.' gah drama makes me talk to myself a lot lately. 

Good morning from part of my world. Hv an awesome day!  

[Vannyah M]

2 minutes ago, tituyphing said:

@honeywell yeah exactly! I feel so too ever since I watched the live broadcast. Epi 17 dedicated to Taek, and many of it can be interpreted to support Taek. Beside the loveline I love epi 17, but everytime loveline scene appears my heart was uneasy by what the other ship would take on this. 

But then I told myself, 'why should you care about what they think, as long as your Junghwan is still the endgame.' gah drama makes me talk to myself a lot lately. 

Good morning from part of my world. Hv an awesome day!  

Ep 17 is really hard to watch before time skip... It gives completely different feeling when you watch it with subs. Well it is likely that that is the aim of this episode. To put JH shippersdown coz i feel uneasy now.

Have a nice day!

[cheetah88]

26 minutes ago, odiaz said:

isnt the photo of TK and DS in TK's journal? CMIIW. that means he brings it everywhere he goes too.

but yeah keeping it on your wallet makes it more intimate. i keep photos of my closest friends on my journal, but only my mother on my wallet

i doubt taek bring his journal everywhere, bcs in the eps when papabear broke taek drawer to find the hotel phone number the journal still there~

[balladblue]

30 minutes ago, Nurul Choerunnisa said:

But IMO, what should be highlighted is her reaction after that night. If she felt something for him, how this awkward and clumsy girl could manage to act nonchalant in front of TK? Remember how nervous she was when she wanted to test JH through fake blind date? Do you think she could pretend as if nothing happened if she liked him? IMHO, she couldn't. Since that kiss didn't mean anything for her and she didn't want her relationship with TK becomes awkward, she decided not to mention anything about it.

So the purpose of this scene is to give TK a chance to be seen as a man by DS... and at the same time... to confirm that even though DS finally sees him as a man... She doesn't feel anything for him.

 

I agree. Her completely casual and comfortable manner of interacting with him the next day is why I at first thought the kiss was just a dream. But like you said, if it is fake, then it'd be a completely pointless scene. Now we just need to wait for a flashback to reveal her thoughts about the kiss. I'm confident they will address the kiss, because that would be a major thing to ignore otherwise. 

Also, like you, I am reassured by the feather slow-mo scene. It's just so hopeful to me. Probably because we know from established tropes that couples who miss each other WILL come together in the end. 

@shunklunk  The feather slow-mo is the missed encounter scene in ep 18. There's a feather that flutters gently in the wind as it drifts into Junghwan's room as he is getting ready for his day.

[MrsSoJiSub]

1 hour ago, honeywell said:

The kiss definitely needs to be addressed and what DS was feeling.   Watching episode 17 now with subs and I can see the other shippers side. They can really make a good argument with this episode.

At first I thought the kiss was a dream, then I watched it again and I think it did happen. Then I realized that if it did happen, it's not a good thing for the other side. Even if it's a dream, it's not a good thing for the other side. He kissed her, she most definitely kissed him back....and then the next day she denied it....and then for 6 six years they never talked about it. There is just no way writers no explanation they can give that I find plausible or believable that Deok Sun and Taek kissed. Deok Sun felt something more than friendship in that kiss and then for 6 years Deok Sun did nothing, nothing, nooothhiing about those feelings!!! She lied and told Taek it was a dream, she held those feelings in for 6 years and now with the reappearance of Junghwan, the kiss with Taek and the feelings of that upon seeing Junghwan it all comes back to her *beats chest like she sees kdrama characters do* WHAT THE richard simmons!?! YOU HAVE GOT TO richard simmons KIDDING ME RIGHT NOW That is the weakest richard simmons I have ever seen/read and oh my lord if things go that way. I will write a letter a day from here in the US, spend as much money as needed everyday to mail it until I get a response, and in my letter I will demand an explanation. She is going to have to explain to me (along with Deok Sun going momentarily blind and believing my Jung Bong and Junghwan are the same size) in what universe richard simmons like this happens!?! I will be like Shiwon's mom who constantly called that writer to change the end of the drama. A letter a day woman until you give me my explanation, a letter a day.

I buy that in episode 17 Deok Sun sees Taek as a man. I buy that he kissed her and she kissed him back. I do not for one second buy that if she felt something she would not tell Taek and lie that it was a dream. NO, I can actually buy that in that moment she lied for various reasons. But if she felt something more than friendship...I DO NOT BUY FOR ONE MILI-SECOND THAT FOR 6 YEARS, 6 DANG YEARS SHE DID NOTHING ABOUT IT!!!  Unless the plane she was stewarding for crashed in the remotest corner of the Sahara dessert, for years no one could find her, and upon being found she had lost her memory of that one moment and that is why in all these years that kiss has never been brought up; then and only then would I buy that Deok Sun felt something and has kept it from Taek all these years. But since this is not what happened to Deok Sun, bull***t. A letter a day woman if you pull that richard simmons (but she won't because that's just crazy). 

If the kiss had not  been filmed the way that it was (which has left many questioning was it real? Was it a dream?) If it had not happened before the time skip but instead happened after, then I would buy that yes she feels something for Taek and has been keeping it to herself for varying reasons these few weeks and after the movie date his showing up sparked a memory and feeling the same as when their lips met and now they will get married and live happily ever after. That is plausible. That is acceptable. If that had happened (and we did not get the confession, hell even if we got the confession) I would be heart broken, but I could eventually accept it. But not the situation we are in right now. That richard simmons just don't fly. It doesn't all come together. It doesn't make sense. Just...WHAT THE richard simmons!!

I actually think that Taek and Deok Sun in the span of sometime during the 6 years may have tried at a secret relationship and it just didn't work out. And or he confessed (even before Junghwan and her came back) and she let him down gently. I know Taek ran to the concert and got there on time. But I think he did that because he obviously still harbors feelings for her and like a Chilbong who couldn't let go even after 100000 years, neither is Taek able to. He's her friend and she's the girl (who for now) he just can't get over but plays the friends game because she has already let him know that is all they will ever be. Nothing in the scene once they got into the concert venue gave any hints of a girl harboring feelings for the guy in front of her, and a kiss they once shared. She was just talking to a friend and begging him not to let the others know (someone made a nice comparison of that scene and the bathroom flasher scene and the talk where her main concern was not letting Junghwan know that she cried) that she had been ditched (remember she told Junghwan -the group was there, but that declaration was directed at him- that she's popular). Someone posted it here and I am starting to agree, Taek may already know of Deok Sun's feelings for Junghwan (when he knew or how -was he told by her, did he too see "something in her eyes") and he knows Junghwan feels the same, but she doesn't, well didn't till episode 18. From their interactions in episode 18 it looks to me that Deok Sun and Taek are as friends as ever, and that's all they are going to remain. He was not the boy man she was thinking of in bed. I believe Deok Sun and Taek tried dating and it didn't work out, he let his feelings be known and she did not recuperate but he'll never let go, and or all that is forthcoming in ep 19 & 20. 

Kiss was real, kiss was not real. She may have felt something then. Twas six years ago and is a past not a present. 

*as always spelling and grammar is not the best, I shall edit when I am less lazy (the feeling of embarrassment I get when someone quotes me and I see all these errors. trust, i'm not as dumb as my internet writing makes me seem. i do know their, there, and they're LOL. i can spell too.

ETA: @honeywell sorry if it seemed like I am yelling at you or saying you're in the wrong. I'm just saying if the writers pull what you say the other ship is thinking, then imma go off on her LOL. I"m not lying about that letter a day.

[mojobobo]

39 minutes ago, vilavila said:

Ok. Time to go watch Yoo Jung did on ep 3.

I was about to ask what the Koreans are thinking,  so thanks for sharing this post.

 

But maybe I'm too used to the slow pace in Reply, I feel like I have a whiplash in CITT ahahahha 

 

Good morning everyone!!! I hope we get some BTS today to tide us over 

 

[parkangel]

I really love YJ Sw reunion scene in R97. It was just an ordinary day, on an ordinary place, who would have thought that they would reunite with the love of their life there, fate and timing. The 1% that Sung Bora talked about.

If writer nim decides JH and DS will be together, I wonder how their reunion scene will be. 

[mmimo]

This thread seriously has no idea about stopping or even resting. 

 

I tried to brace myself reading that thesis in MT and feeling so glad when someone attacked her by saying that it's better to take a deeper look on the script instead of the props. Also the opinion given by @fleshwithoutblood which was posted by @wizengamot. You guys are killing it.  Till then let's try to calm down and keep spazzing happily because this ship will face something huge this Friday.

 

[Vannyah M]

"Reply series's PD and writers are very famous in Korea.
because they constantly use trivial foreshadowing.
There is a lot of foreshadowing.
ex)JH's diary(partly seen next page, mother's a meaning word),
rain-TV program(It's freaking awesome),
fiance ring (Air force's man/female ring are different in size),
Forrest Gump' feather (Amazingly, it appeared since a long time ago<ep13>),
movie ticket and chewing gum,
pillow(at the taek's birthday party),
the position of the mirror, dolls, etc. there are countless foreshadowing."

This is a comment from Korean viewer, i had to share it here. So feather appeared on ep 13? Someone saw that? I dont care about other foreshadowings or clues I`m just interasted in  feather .

 

@balladblue please inform me if you check it coz i`m really curious. That feather was like the most beautiful scene for me and i can not believe that i`ve missed it in ep 13