If I Ain't Got You

[resetlove]

Kim Dongwan(shinhwa) vs Younha

watch the video before voting =D

dongwan -> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=azRRTMldC8Y

younha -> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=66T9B_TJXLw

original singer is Alicia Keys btw...

[butterflyeffect]

Dongwan is good, but I saw Younha's rendition of the song a while ago and it totally amazed me.

[Guest gravitie]

i like both's. but i got to say YOUNHA's was better. ^^

[Guest jaycee725]

both were good...but becoz the original was alicia keys so

younha sings better than him.

i like younha's voice...she has the potential and her

English pronunciation was good.

[Guest TVXQ_superjunior]

>.<" THEY BOTH ARE SUPERB!!! I LOVE IT!!! But i have to go with Younha...

[Guest dumbstruckk]

dong wan was amazing but when I heard younha's, WOW! speechless!

[Guest rairai]

Younha, to me, was better of th two.

Well, both did amazingly good.

But Younha's pronounciation was better and clearer.

Kim dongwan's, well, his words were gibberish.

But i ove him, so it doesnt matter(:

[Guest virginangelic]

Younha was the better of the two I think. Even though both delivered wonderful renditions, Younha delivered a better rendition. I guess it's because her pronounciation and pronunciation was far clearer. Who IS this girl anyways?! Her voice is powerful! I like it.

[Gullwings]

dongwans XDD~... anyways I love J lims version the best ^____^

[Guest _ping_]

both are damn good...

I like DongWans more..^^;

[Guest raina_flor]

sorry, when it comes to Dongwan, i am just subjective, I still vote for him. Younha is great but hearing a guy sing the song gives the song a new twist for me

[Guest hahaheehee]

omg, thanks for introducing me to Younha! I've never heard her music but after watching that clip of her singing AND playing the piano so effortlessly, I'm impressed. I think she did the cover of If I Ain't Got You very well.

(but I voted for Dongwan because I'm biased... I voted for him first before I watched Younha's clip. )

[Guest hseliz]

kudos for both of them.

they sang it beautifully in their own ways..

DongWan sounds realy great..

YounHa too..

voted for Younha..

[Guest bk.]

i like yoonha better

but lee kichan (not on the list) is really really good he made it his own song

[Guest smiless]

My vote goes to Younha. I love her voice. It fits well with the song. When watching Dongwan's video, I just couldn't get past his fobby accent (no offense), but I totally give him props. He sang it well. If only he had better pronunciation.

Here's a video of Younha singing the whole song for those of you who want to see it:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OnQn6_tRv2s...ted&search=

PS. If I could pick her, my vote would definitely go to May Doni instead. She's incredible when she sings this song. Absolutely amazing.

[_shin_]

love Dongwan but i voted for Younha..her voice is very powerful! Go Younha!!

[Guest kiirya]

both are great but i think younha's amazing.

her voice is really nice.

[motoway065]

Younha was better imo so I voted for her.

[kiki]

younha... she could play the piano <3

[Guest Nye~]

Dongwan is good.

But Younha is better.

OMG I wish I could sing like her!