Jump to content


  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by insertusernamehere

  1. Love this! He's so mature for such a young actor. And a great public speaker too! First "TED talk" with fangirls heart-eyeing in the audience If anyones interested I can translate it into English later. But basically he's really brave in facing criticism about his acting head on (even the dumb big eyes comments), discussing his insecurities, advocating for following your dreams by being really prepared and working really hard, and revealing that he's a super nerd who spent 4 months during the audition period doing nothing but reading the source novel, watching multiple HSDS versions, and reading online comments and analyses to prepare for his role lol he's so adorable!!!
  2. I'm subbing ep 27 now, it's so much fun to look back at what happened before all the melo stuff! Oh good innocent times! This is my first time subbing on youtube and it's quite easy! (thankfully there are already folks who helped put in the time stamps!) If you don't speak Chinese, please help with putting in the time stamps, we can then put in translation! If you don't have time, please do a review and edit/fix mistakes/typos (e.g. I saw a line that says "when did you tell my father" (from Bu Hui) but it was supposed to be "when will you tell my father", etc.) Everything and anything helps!
  3. Ok so since I can't get over this drama, I started reading the novel (which was fully translated in my native language, Vietnamese). The last chapter was very satisfying; it really explained why Gu Tingye and Minglan are the way they are. Since the English translation for the novel is only up to chapter 78 (there are 219 in total), I translated key excerpts from the last chapter here, hopefully it gives you some closure/entertainment as it did me The full doc has translation footnotes etc., but I'll put here the very last conversation that they had (it'll be more impactful if you read from the beginning! But if you're pressed for time, this convo will suffice). See under spoiler tag:
  4. I only watched a bit of the 94 version and it was so long ago I can't remember, but based on the clips it would seem that it has the same melodramatic flair lol it's the same writer. I think the director is key here - he showed the same deft handle of the materials with LOCH 17.
  5. I noticed this! (From watching interviews and bts). Yukee and Joseph have really nice voices though. Is it because they have an accent?
  6. This scene was really nice in the novel too. You can't tell here but the "voiceover" in WJ's head was saying how the lipstick mark was a light shade of pink, with a hint of fragrance, and he was moved (meaning he was moved by her femininity/presence). It was quite romantic! (I'm too lazy to find the whole quote here )
  7. I actually highly recommend LOCH '17. It's quite loyal to the book, and is very fresh and youthful. One of the better versions of this story.
  8. Can someone translate what was written on each of their lanterns? Thank you! Also I was thinking...WJ's passion for saving the people, while fitting with his personality, seems a bit out of nowhere given that we didn't really see him thinking about that until he was forced into the Ming sect leader role. If he was someone truly passionate about this issue, it would make more sense why he didn't want to leave with MM. In the novel the war wasn't emphasized as much, and WJ also didn't constantly talk about the importance of saving Han people from Yuan.
  9. I wish they cut more of the beginning. There was like 15 eps of background and childhood story, while it fleshes out a lot of characters most of them end up dead early anyway so....
  10. I agree with everyone here about the payoff. All this drama would only be worth it if WJ dramatically left everything even when the war was still going - it would be a huge gesture from him since we know how guilt-trippable he is, and how he insists on keeping even the most stupid promise (marrying girls he didn't love, twice). I think the writer struggles with having an ending that feels epic enough. In the novel, the climax seems to be the Shaolin arc, after that it just kinda meanders for a while with not much going on. The reason why WJ left Ming sect in the novel also seems random (Zhu Yuan Zhang pretended to poison him, he got disappointed). In a way upping ZYZ's scheming level makes WJ's final decision to leave more compelling, but at the same time like you all said, we were robbed of that actual decision process. He was gonna leave after the war was done anyway, what did ZYZ's plot of killing ZM's dad even add? Maybe in this way, with all the most important people in their lives gone, they can truly be together unburdened. I don't dislike the concept of this ending, it's the execution that leaves much to be desired. Re: kiss and whatnot, I've always thought him drawing her eyebrows was the most romantic gesture. The simplicity of her request, the intimacy, and the implication that he'd be by her side forever to do this, is what does it for me I'm of the probably controversial school of thought that marriage is just a social contract to protect people, and having kids was an economic necessity (more labor, back when we didn't have machines), so I'm perfectly happy with no wedding and no kid. Commitment is more important, and we know that they're committed. Re: YX, ommmggg where was YX in all of this?! I'm happy he wasn't involved in the s***ty plotting so he could remain Top Boss in terms of being Hot & Perfect, but I need YX on my screen! Re: YX & JXF, I think he knew how stubborn she was, and how committed she was to Er Mei, so if he had tried to find her, she'd probably kill herself or something like that. He also knew that being together would make JXF truly miserable. So I'm happy he respected her wish. As for WJ and ZM, she's free and unburdened from everything, and already has the tendency to tell WJ to "go away" without ever really meaning it, so I think in this case WJ has better grounds to ignore her request and go find her.
  11. Re: why Ming sect wants him to stay: He's the Katniss of this District 12 revolution!
  12. The intro is out on YouTube today and they already have a different opening song! I too would be curious about the differences. Also want to know where to stream since a friend of mine speaks Cantonese but not Mandarin, and eng sub has been slow so far for her.
  13. Now I'm having fun imagining what went through the writer's head: "ok so in the novel there was a scene where Wuji wanted to ask ZM's strategy opinion since he's stuck and she's much better at it than him, but he can't because he doesn't want to put her in a difficult spot (fighting against her family). What if we jazz it up by having her (fake) die and him crying at her grave?"
  14. Ahhh I see. I don't disagree, but the melo so far either makes me laugh (throwing away the umbrella! In the rain!) Or cry, so I'm happy with it
  15. That's so weird that people are so protective of canon. The Tvb version (2000) made up a ton of stuff too, and it wasn't even good. Maybe I've been trained by kdrama but I enjoy the melo :\ and enjoy comparing it to the original to see what creative touch they've put to it. Praying that fans will recognize the value of the added stuff
  16. @40somethingahjumma agree! We're missing some really iconic flirty lines from WJ, like " you better make it up to me with your body because you ruined my wedding night", and the pretending to be a married couple hijinks. But like you said the melodrama and the skinship is good too lol
  17. Did anyone find it unfair that WJ didn't remove ZM's clothing like he did for ZZR when he cured ZM with his internal energy? Also by his logic shouldn't he marry ZM already since he did touch her body twice already, on her skin (Snake island when she was stabbed and XZ removed a layer from ZM for WJ to treat her, and yesterday with the shoulder poison)? Justice for MinMin! Equal rights to get clothing removed through convenient plot devices!
  18. I thought he was actually pretty good, on the other hand... Yuqee don't pull a Park Shin Hye please! (psh doesn't ever move her lips)
  19. They also changed how strongly WJ reacted to ZZR's crime, so I also hope this means no more "you owe me one thing" from ZZR!
  20. I think it's added. After XX's arc in Shaolin he didn't appear in the story again. In that scene he wore monk clothes, and all the fighting at Shaolin must have concluded otherwise they wouldn't be sitting in a room like that, talking.
  21. @arniechow thank you for letting us know! I did have to search by the Chinese name haha but I think I found it: Spotify HSDS 2019 OST For some reason the opening song is not there? @Don Yu see link above!
  22. @dramagirlslove good point about the plot hole of YL getting out of the island. I can't recall how they explained it in the novel either. I think we have to just accept this lot hole One thing I like about Jin Yong's novels is that you almost never have a Mary Sue. Everyone is imperfect in some ways. I think we all recognize that WJ in essence is a very weak-willed man. He can't go against other people's wishes and lets others decide things for him. In real life situations that I've witnessed, a relationship with such a man is either doomed or rocky. ZM, awesome as she is, isn't without flaws either. She is arrogant, and she can be mean. But somehow in many ways, she complements WJ; it's a case where opposite attracts and then builds on each other. I really hope they air all 8 eps next week instead of waiting for another week!! The first week of airing they released 8 eps so it wouldn't be the first time if they decided to do so.
  • Recent Awards

    • Soompier Level 5

    • Soompier Level 4

    • Soompier Level 3

    • Soompier Level 2

    • Soompier Level 1

  • Create New...