[Park Bo Gum ❤ Girl's Day Hyeri aka REPLY 1988 TAEK x DEOKSUN]

On 5/19/2016 at 10:11 PM, packmule3 said:

Brava!  You got it.  It was intentional. 

This is another info that was discussed in PM only between a couple of posters. I didn’t want to write about it out in the open because I felt people were still skeptical that JB was the culprit who took the chocolate meant for TK. And I didn’t want to waste my time [and theirs] giving proofs to them ad nauseum.  I feel like that ill-fated Cassandra in Homer's Iliad.

But since you brought it up, let me tell you what I said in PM. 

The discrepancy in minutes is proof that somebody – specifically, JB -- tampered with the videocam to erase or delete any evidence of him taking the chocolate from the jacket. It wasn't a mistake of the editor; it was deliberately done.  But viewers would only come to this conclusion if 1) they were paying attention to the minutes on the camcorder, and 2) they understood who the culprit was. Of course, the scriptwriter was expecting a lot from the viewers, and unfortunately, it was a hit-and-miss.  

JB rewound the tape and that was why the videocam was registering 27m26s when DS put in the chocolate in the jacket and 27m17s when the boys came out the room. There were missing minutes or minutes unaccounted for because the tape was rewound. 

All the other boys were in that room so none of them could have taken the chocolate and fiddled around with the camcorder. Jinjoo wouldn’t know how to operate the camcorder. Only JB would have both the know-how to work the videocam [he was MacGyver, remember?] and the motive to steal the chocolate [he was upset that he lost that video arcade game to TK].

As I said from the beginning, JB took the chocolate.

Anyway, good job. And I'm glad you posted.  

Dear,

Thank you for the answer.

But could you please explain this too? (I don't know how this scene just really caught my attention...)

Below are 2 snapshots (again), the first one is what did happen when DS was trying to hide chocolate into the jacket, you can notice there was a black pair of shoes at the bottom right corner

The second snapshot is the footage of the scene in the first snapshot, which was revealed later at the end of ep.2

It seems that there is no black shoes, only white shoes are so visible.

Only DS and JJ were there all the time we can't say JB did something... The difference here is between what is real and what is recorded (!?)

In my country there is one saying for cheating guys: changing things from white to black LOL is PD-nim joking too or do you have any explanation for this discrepancy?

Looking forwards to your response, it was such a nice treat to read your post that JB tampered the camcorder hahah never thought of that!!

[Park Bo Gum ❤ Girl's Day Hyeri aka REPLY 1988 TAEK x DEOKSUN]

Hello!

I am newbie here but I have something needed to be answered by you guys LOL because I am rewatching Ep 2 (actually not the whole ep but some favourite cuts so my questions may seem shallow...) anw!

The first snapshot: DS slid the chocolate bar into the jacket at 27m26s

The second snapshot: the boys came out of the room to go eat tteokbokki at 27m17s (?!? how could that happen they should have come out after she hid the chocolate not before...)

Is that intentional or mere mistake of the editor??? What do you think?