Baylack Posted June 22, 2020 Share Posted June 22, 2020 35 minutes ago, luvlove said: I agree, plus the director's comments about them hanging out with him a couple times, too. I have always believed that HB maybe made the decision to pull the plug on a seemingly distant previous relationship when he started getting to know SYJ. In early December of 2018, Vast said, “We have confirmed that Hyun Bin and Kang So-ra recently broke up after drifting apart due to their busy schedules." Their statement says, "We have confirmed" as if they did not ever announce and instead waited until sources asked. I figure they actually broke up weeks earlier. Are you sure you don't mean December 2017? 1 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SHpectator Posted June 22, 2020 Share Posted June 22, 2020 30 minutes ago, dreamerofRIRI said: But if you recall HB seemed to recognise that some of the crew were from SITR? They weren't the actors in SITR else he wouldn't have asked them if they were the SITR crew ???? Im not sure but i think i saw a tweeted photo where they (the SITR staff) were holding a big-as* banner and that's how HB recognized them? 3 3 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
itspeanutbutterjellytime Posted June 22, 2020 Share Posted June 22, 2020 43 minutes ago, ElectricHearts said: I still read it as they filmed again while she was doing SITR and not that he actually visited her on SITR set. Or is it just me that read it that way still? Lol. We know she's busy April to early May with SITR. She had some days off on her schedule but now much. Same, I am inclined towards this view as well. It is unlike SYJ to slip up such information - I feel as though HB coming into her filming set is something quite intimate and it didn’t seem their relationship was that as yet at the time? But that time there seemed to be something blooming already, maybe quite slowly. @dreamerofRIRI As for this, If Im not mistaken the crew came up with a banner of some sort to cheer her on and probably their interactions during the promo made him deduce that, rather than him having met them before at the set. But that moment was a big “more than co-stars” vibe from HB lol. 4 3 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Felizak@t Posted June 22, 2020 Share Posted June 22, 2020 1 hour ago, Furmom_jds said: Hi. Can i ask what is the "night walk sighting" you mentioned, when is that? I think I overlooked that topic and I got so excited when I read this phrase. Thank you for sharing! Sorry to quote Hello..I can't point the pages where it was discussed here partly. It will need some backreading. It first came out in March and resurfaced here early May. Basically, it was just an account of a visiting Taiwanese or Chinese in Korea whose Uncle live near HB or SYJ (yes, I'm that forgetful I can only remember my delulu). That said ahjussi mentioned to have met BINJIN while out on a walk. That neighbor also said something else that you would find on that written account. They were considered plain rumor since we don't have a picture, right? Let your delulu play. 18 2 3 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Popular Post ninjayejin Posted June 22, 2020 Popular Post Share Posted June 22, 2020 Quote 2017 - They start shooting TN late 2017 ( short filming - they barely interact) HB is not single. He had his boundaries set straight. Don't backtrack on that please . We are not "that type" of fans in here. - HB is back on the market . December 2017. 2018 - They meet again for re-shoots - promo shoots - commentaries etc - He visits her in SITR set at some point before the drama wraps in early May? - SYJ is doing promo for BWY right after the drama wraps - talks about marriage without hinting on anything but she changed her opinion slightly from before where she she says her parents don't push her to marry - where she doesn't think about settling down because she is comfortable on her own. - HB starts filming in Spain in May for MOTA . - They doing NT era promos starting June - as month processes they look more comfortable with each other. HB probably was cloned somewhere and replaced .... - YJ is more active on her insta where she posts videos with both of them . - More promotion videos from promotions BTS - them playing a game for promotion reasons - etc - September 2018 HB says he is single and busy to actually date .... - October 2018 - Rampant premiere - YJ attends with her MSTeam CEO . - First sightings posted online about seeing them on a golf course November . 2019 - MOTA wrap up party - We have first rumor of traveling together and denial straight away January 10 while there is no evidence other than people saying they saw them together. #1 denial - both agencies - January 21 - they are seen shopping together and go on denial spree . #2 denial - both agencies - March - rumor of HB doing a new drama . - April - SYJ enters negotiations to join the same drama - In the mean time they both attend the Medheal event - 22.4 ? - May 22 - official confirmation of them doing the drama together . - May of 2019 he talks about might not "public property" anymore . - Filming starts for CLOY early August . - September in Mongolia - airport stress avoidance from the paparazzi - November 2019 - first promo interview from tvN - Press conference December 9 - press interviews - both don't deny nor confirm due to the drama. - Filming stops at some point to allow staff take a break due to the weather conditions between ep6-7 - Filming resumes - more articles about them - more fan speculation. - A rumor about marriage comes out of nowhere based on nothing really. - Filming stops again because of the weather conditions ( they film a lot outside) . ep10-11. - A rumor about them breaking up based on the filming being postponed ( WHAT? ) comes out . - CLOY wraps filming couple of days before the finale - due to allowing the actors rest in between. - Wrap party Feb 17 - Clearly in good terms - sitting together - hug in the end of the drama . Cast tease them. - More fan speculation feed the piranhas in combination with the drama being popular . Series of ridiculous articles based on fans theories resurface. Last denial 18th February 2019 #3 denial. one agency. February - June - YJ has no interview post CLOY - seems to be on hiatus . Pandemic spreads from SK to the rest of world rapidly . - YJ donates money for pandemic relief - HB releases a letter about it . The pandemic in SK has epicenter YJ's hometown. Days later because people can't accept a celeb can donate without the world know about - we found out HB actually donated as well for the relief. - SK control like aces in the whole world the pandemic . - HB starts finally production of "Bargaining" - YJ is on hiatus - she hasn't accepted any interviews or CFs from February up to early June . - HB does CFs left and right along filming his film. - YJ posts about 2 pics on instagram and comments on her friends insta and we finally know she is alive and well . June - HB does an interview where he remembers an interview where YJ mentioned his soft hair ???? Said interview in 2018.... - Baeksangs voting ends - We get confirmation they both will attend . - Awards - They both attend -and talk to each other - evidence based - the camera showed them looking at each others sitting direction - and talking while laughing. - They win the popularity award in individual categories. Robbed of everything else . - Wearing same brand - posing together for an individual category with one award . Speeches complementing- completing each other. - days later more fan cams resurface - YeJin obviously aware of the hidden camera in the venue - HB evidently anxious - keeps playing with his hand while looking the direction of the camera. - Both walking - slowly side by side - less than 1 meter distance with each other . - YJ finally posts on her instagram the flower shop she opened from the fans gifts for her debut anniversary. - YJ "thanks" fans by liking her pictures from the award - and pictures of both of them. - YJ finally decides to go back on doing CFs with brands she worked before for years . A loyal woman is loyal . - HB continues his CF spree . Bargaining wraps up and picture with him looking "tired" and wearing a puffy jacket in the summer is posted. To summarize : If they are indeed together - and we are not clowns since early 2019 - then things are clear from a POV of someone mature and logical. My hypothesis is one : they met in 2017 while filming - nothing happened between them . HB is back in market - they meet again for working reasons - they both are the same age - similar interests and communicate well together. They are getting closer as friends - NT promo tour allows them to get know each other. I know visiting her on site seems off but YJ said it herself before anyone else. It's not suspicious - they worked together and they had promotions ahead . It only suggests he was interested and they were growing closer together- he worked with one of her friends before . For me they grew closer as time passed by - they both mature individuals - its not we see each other and date straight away. All I can say is between NT promo tour - and CLOY they are different in their interactions. YeJin has always expressed her views for marriage without feeling she has to lie or hide things. She is always mature on her views about relationships - her views about work - she has worked with the same people for 20 years- she is close with her team - her CEO - she is someone who said she picks a job based on the script-director and cast and not the salary . She picked works unconventional but with respect to women , her characters are always strong with flaws but she shines in each role she picks . She is picky in her craft . She works herself out - how many videos we have seen where she tires herself crying . The same applies for HB - he is meticulous about his work - especially post marines - he does his stunts and even got back pain when filming in CA because he wanted the scene to look perfect. He is more reserved - I won't say shy anymore but he is prefers not to talk much unless needed - he doesn't look like he is fooling around. They both have a lot of experience in the industry and are well respected . You can only hope in life to find someone to understand what you going through, respect your work and allow you to be yourself without power imbalance or overwhelming jealousy . 29 8 4 6 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Willowkatcmr888 Posted June 22, 2020 Share Posted June 22, 2020 1 hour ago, Baylack said: Are you sure you don't mean December 2017? 1 hour ago, Baylack said: Yes, you are right it was Dec 2017 that they (......) announce thier break up. @Onewaytrain HB was practically single and free to pursue the apple of his eye starting Jan 2018 onwards.. Maybe ( just maybe or shall I safely presumed ) that HB made it clear that he is clear and free b4 he will do the next big step. 5 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Samsam Posted June 22, 2020 Share Posted June 22, 2020 A new photo was released today by Ma:nyo i believe this was from her pictorial a few weeks ago. 12 12 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Kahlua2019 Posted June 22, 2020 Share Posted June 22, 2020 8 minutes ago, Willowkatcmr888 said: Yes, you are right it was Dec 2017 that they (......) announce thier break up. @Onewaytrain HB was practically single and free to pursue the apple of his eye starting Jan 2018 onwards.. Maybe ( just maybe or shall I safely presumed ) that HB made it clear that he is clear and free b4 he will do the next big step. The break-up with the ex could even have happened months before Dec.2017 but only got confirmed & announced to the public in Dec.2017... no one breaks up & immediately announces it ASAP. There would always be a gap between such occurrences... 11 1 4 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
loveintheair Posted June 22, 2020 Share Posted June 22, 2020 Deleted. Thanks for reminder. 3 1 2 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ri Se Ri Posted June 22, 2020 Share Posted June 22, 2020 11 minutes ago, Kahlua2019 said: The break-up with the ex could even have happened months before Dec.2017 but only got confirmed & announced to the public in Dec.2017... no one breaks up & immediately announces it ASAP. There would always be a gap between such occurrences... Absolutely. 6 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TotoroSY Posted June 22, 2020 Share Posted June 22, 2020 @Samsam Thanks for the new YJ Ma:nyo pictures (btw, why is this brand name so complex to type??). She looks so naturally gorgeous in the ads. Glowing!! Another small precious Binjin candy ~ love how she so naturally grab and shake his arm, and he just as naturally reply her without even looking up. Like a cozy household scene. It's still funny to see this receipt again, when both answered CHANNEL 20 for TVN at their home(s) Thank you lady MC for asking that question LOL!! 7 15 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
charray Posted June 22, 2020 Share Posted June 22, 2020 On 6/21/2020 at 12:55 PM, luffie said: Does anyone know if the content of the club and the forum is different or the same? My 2 cents on the differences: 1) Being a closed club restricted to limited number of users, one can discuss more sensitive topics without worry that the content will be plastered all over social media the next day. Several of us had encountered the disconcerting experiences of seeing our posts being reposted onto IG and/or twitter by other people who are lurking in the main shipper thread. 2) Some shippers may want to engage in more delulu speculation or may wish to discuss some grey /questionable clues if they are indeed receipts while other shippers may prefer to be more grounded and only accepting credible evidence so the club may be a good place for like minded people to discuss together with other like minded people without triggering the displeasure of the rest who are not so inclined. 3) The club owner can organise the club in very structured way by creating sections and divisions within the club. Within each section/ division, any member can start any topic so it will be easy to find and search for content by looking at the sections and topics. In the main shipper thread, it is difficult (if not impossible) to find specific previously posted topic or content unless you backread every page and it is daunting since we are nearing 1000 pages now. 4) For the well organised club, it will be easy to skip certain sections and topics that one is not interested in but not in the main shipper thread where one will see every post in the main shipper thread. It will lead to unhappiness and ruffled feathers of some if the main shipper thread becomes too heavy on pushing certain narrative on SYJ or HB. Whereas for the club, we can create a special corner for fans who want to do posts after posts focussed on their pet subject such as HB kindness or SYJ Chungmuro success if they wish without putting others to sleep or rubbing others up the wrong way. The 2 Binjin clubs were created recently so still in the early stages of finding its shape. I guess everyone is still figuring how to use the club and what to discuss at the hideout versus what to discuss on the main shipping thread. 4 2 11 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BinJin99 Posted June 22, 2020 Share Posted June 22, 2020 1 hour ago, Willowkatcmr888 said: Yes, you are right it was Dec 2017 that they (......) announce thier break up. @Onewaytrain HB was practically single and free to pursue the apple of his eye starting Jan 2018 onwards.. Maybe ( just maybe or shall I safely presumed ) that HB made it clear that he is clear and free b4 he will do the next big step. 1 hour ago, Kahlua2019 said: The break-up with the ex could even have happened months before Dec.2017 but only got confirmed & announced to the public in Dec.2017... no one breaks up & immediately announces it ASAP. There would always be a gap between such occurrences... I PERSONALLY think that HB sent a clear signal to YJ that he is free and single 1 day before filming of Negotiation is finished. Dec 8 2017: break up news made public (they ended their relationship recently due to busy schedule) Dec 9 2017: filming of The Negotiation is finished Notes: The Negotiation Filming began June 17, 2017 in Paju, South Korea Filming finished December 9, 2017. Hyun-Bin plays a villain for the first time in his acting career. 6 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ElectricHearts Posted June 22, 2020 Share Posted June 22, 2020 @dreamerofRIRI I think regardless he was watching SITR lol.. If they met up during April for reshoots, he knows she is also filming the show then lol. Who knows maybe the studio between SITR and TN set is the same that day! We will never know which day this "meeting" happened or what her SITR schedule was like that day. The show was brought up earlier when he was doing TN interviews with her lol during TN promo period. Plus their TN co star, Lee Joo-Young, also at that premiere with them was on SITR. So if anything it is very obvious, the SITR production team came for that premiere Plus they are holding signs lol.. @loveintheair pretty certain her food truck was the one he received around April 22 that had TN advertisement on it. Plus he got americano that day lol. Like she could have sent him more or even visited him. She isn't doing much as we know lol besides golfing 6 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
lovelife Posted June 22, 2020 Share Posted June 22, 2020 Deleted. 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BinJin99 Posted June 22, 2020 Share Posted June 22, 2020 HB did audition for his first villain role in his career in The Negotiation. 3 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Furmom_jds Posted June 22, 2020 Share Posted June 22, 2020 Done. 1 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ninjayejin Posted June 22, 2020 Share Posted June 22, 2020 The tweets that were deleted , came from an unreliable source thus why person locked their account . Maybe we should refrain discussing about it openly. Since it’s not reliable evidence . And it was one of the reasons none of us brought it up on the main thread . Thus why two clubs created . I wanna remind why two clubs were created . For the relief of the main thread of not needed and sometimes harmful discussion and speculation based on nothing concrete and allowing people in one of them to speculate and make judgement speculation based on evidence without arguing constantly here about what can harm and what cannot and allowing people to be delulu as well without the same issue . It seems the clubs serve no purpose because the thread is deriving Again from its main purpose and what we try to maintain post 3rd denial in here . We have DMs and clubs ? Can we keep certain things away from prying eyes ? This thread reminds Public . Thank you 2 2 3 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Cherie Cee Posted June 22, 2020 Share Posted June 22, 2020 Slightly off topic, but I might just as well considering things are kinda slow. I just finished watching Romance is a Bonus Book and I am totally captivated by the story of this drama. It is directed by CLOY director Lee Jeong Hyo. Excellent work, which he directed right before CLOY (broadcasted Jan to March 2019). In one of the episodes, the leads were watching TV at home and for some reason, camera focuses on the movie being shown, none other than SYJ in that soju then kissing scene in A Moment to Remember! Perhaps this was a little clue that CLOY was already in the horizon. The drama also has our favorite ajumma, Kim Sun-Young in another performance. She is everywhere and always delivering good acting. I am really liking the works of Director Lee. Romance is a Bonus Book has Lee Jong suk and Lee Na Young as the leads. Such a well made drama, so heart warming, so natural, nothing forced, wonderful characters. So if you're looking , for a good drama, this won't disappoint. Or if you are just looking for something to do as our ship sails slowly but surely, you can watch this. 6 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
lovebirds Posted June 22, 2020 Share Posted June 22, 2020 YJ normally choses good scripts over popular directors when considering her projects. 5 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now