Quantcast
Jump to content
0ly40

[Drama 2019-2020] Crash Landing on you, 사랑의 불시착

Ending prediction   

210 members have voted

This poll is closed to new votes
  1. 1. What will happen to the OTP at the end of this drama?

    • Sweet happy ending for Ri-ri in SK
    • Cue sad music ..the divide is just too great ..the OTP will be separated
    • An open ending where they will meet again on the bridge in Switzerland ...

  • Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.
  • Poll closed on 02/15/2020 at 01:37 PM

Recommended Posts

8 hours ago, frozentundra said:

 

I had a discussion elsewhere over this. We concluded that it must be in Romansch (one of the four national languages of Switzerland) because it isn't French, German, or Italian. 

 

YES, that's also my number 1 guess as I've stated earlier. Someone in youtube said it's Finnish but seems he/ she is not 100% sure either since  he/ she asked to refer to a Finnish song. It sounds more like Romansch to me after I listened to a few videos of people speaking and also songs in Romansh .

 

 

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 minutes ago, Ottoke said:

I have a question about the time line.

 

1) HB & SYJ first met in Switzerland until they first met in North Korea. How many years apart?

 

2) SYJ stays in NK for how many years?

 

3) HB went to SK after how many years SJY left NK?

 

 

1. It was 7-year apart.

2. Seri only stayed in the north for a few months, I think it's only 3 months ( maybe I'm wrong)

3. It is only 3 weeks when RJH goes to the south after Seri is sent back to the south.

  • Like 6

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, Eliza Marlowe said:

Guys! Please do not read netizenbuzz comments about our drama surpassing goblin in rating. That site is really toxic. K-netizens still hate, degrade and disrate our drama, even our proved them wrong. I'm just getting pissed.

 

Oh really? I've seen some negative comments too on twitter and other social media. I guess Goblin fans were really upset since it has held the top ratings for 3 years, plus most of the articles compared CLOY ratings with Goblin (it actually overtook Reply 1988 but most sites get the ratings wrong). I love both CLOY and Goblin, both tell unique and wonderful stories. Don't know why people need to compare and squabble about it.....

 

 

  • Like 4
  • Insightful 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Putting aside wishful thinking, excessive optimism, and conspiracy theories, the writer prepared us for the ending by referencing the story of Jingnyeo, the weaver girl who falls in love with Gyeonu, the herder.

 

The Cowherd and the Weaver Girl is a Chinese folk tale. The tale of the cowherd and the weaver girl is a love story between Zhinü (織女; the weaver girl, symbolizing the star Vega) and Niulang (牛郎; the cowherd, symbolizing the star Altair). Their love was not allowed, thus they were banished to opposite sides of the heavenly river (symbolizing the Milky Way). Once a year, on the 7th day of the 7th lunar month, a flock of magpies would form a bridge to reunite the lovers for one day. There are many variations of the story.  source

 

What makes this story admirable is that Niulang has endured a lot to reunite with Zhinu. There were certainly many obstacles that prevented their reunion. However, Niulang never gave up on reuniting with Zhinu. Therefore, why must we give up if the obstacles seem tough or nearly impossible? It is a matter of how will we deal with them.  source

 

Concluding the story with their reunion ends it at the highest point.  All that comes after is supplied by the viewers' imaginations, and since we all imagine something different, we all get the best possible story.  :) 

 

Well done!!

 

 

My favorite scene:

f82d2f45ce80cfed2b598319dfbc5661728ec98d

251c81ce36484749827f1d39ca0fd252d5a43c92

9ef1da54046f51f4ac5030c838782298f1fc2bf9

 

 

  • Like 12
  • Love 5
  • Insightful 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
22 minutes ago, Ottoke said:

I have a question about the time line.

 

1) HB & SYJ first met in Switzerland until they first met in North Korea. How many years apart?

 

2) SYJ stays in NK for how many years?

 

3) HB went to SK after how many years SJY left NK?

 

 

1) 7 years

2)1 month

3) I think  2 weeks after she left NK.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, jamy47 said:

I understand why many are feeling kinda empty regarding the ending, like they wanted more. It's normal because HB and SYJ have so much chemistry, we wanted to see more of them as a couple because the entire drama they never got to be really together, they were always running from danger or staying away because it's forbidden. When we see two actors with so much chemistry, it would be good to actually see the beautiful moments when they are really together doing normal couple stuff. This is the one thing i regret after watching.  A second season would be so perfect because then it would start with them being a couple.

 

I get it. Really. I really do. I would not have complained if we got a lot of fanservice for an entire episode. I have to confess that my faith in the writers started to waiver a couple of episodes ago. It felt like the plot was losing steam and we would end up with such a rushed finale. But boy was I wrong.  The emotional payoff made up for me trying to watch the doldrums of the drama. In fact, I found it fitting not seeing our OTP experience "NORMAL" stuff.  They were never a "normal" couple to begin with. This is something that the writers were great at in this drama. They never veered off their identity. None of the characters went rogue. No one became completely unrecognizable to try and fit the demands of the viewers. RJH was always this innocent, loyal and upstanding man. He had a petulant side when around his parents but morphs into the reliably mature dude around Seri. Quite frankly, watching the inexperienced RJH all swoony and "touchy feely" would have been out of character. Same goes for Seri. She had to put on this tough woman facade to protect herself, but hiding behind the mask is a woman just longing to be appreciated and loved, full of childish antics and kindness. It seemed that when she survived those self-destructive thoughts, she simply just lived on and started to "let herself go" by dating around. Finding RJH with whom she had such deep emotional connection with, he was the first man he's ever wanted to be his COMPANION. Not to sound prudish, but her feelings for RJH went beyond lust.

  • Like 14
  • Love 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Will the cast and crew receive a reward vacation for the monumental success of CLOY? I sure hope they do! They did a fantastic job and deserve all the accolades 

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I feel like online comments are always going to trend to the negative. Basically, online trolls will criticize people for their faults (ie for not being "the best,"), but once you reach the top, the same people simply cannot handle someone having it all, so they immediately begin to tear that person down. Don't think about miserable people living their lives online in miserable ways. Be happy for all the good in the world--which includes a fantastic drama!

 

A couple of observations about the drama. While it was horribly tragic for our second lead guy to die, I think that it cemented in Dan's mind the fact that there really was a guy who loved her more than his own life. (She felt hurt that RJH would risk so much for Seri earlier, but here is a guy who literally would do that for her, too.) 

 

Also, another thing I like about kdramas (as opposed to western storytelling) that really came out in this is that for every role, there is the positive and negative side. Western stories sometimes take a negative character through such a transformation that they turn into someone else entirely. They give up that role and take on another. I've observed that in kdramas, it's more a transformation to find your own best self (instead of turning into someone else). Seri could have gone to NK and decided that her old life was soulless, and given up the store, the clothing line, the whole lifestyle. Instead, she came back and discovered how to humanize her role. She used her position to better the lives of her employees, to bring cheer to the ahjummahs over the border with the cosmetic line for them, etc. I've seen this in other dramas, too (the guy in Masters Sun comes to mind), and I really like it. We can't just turn into someone else. We have to look for our own best strengths and choose the positive side of ourselves over the negative. 

 

As for the ending...the real life future of NK and SK remains an unwritten book. I choose to hope that someday there will be a peaceful, happy ending there, and I imagine in the drama that it happened and that they did get married and live happily ever after in Switzerland and got their twins and everything else they wanted. :)

  • Like 15
  • Love 8

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Site Admin said:

 

I really thought RJH wanted Seri to stop running because he feared that the NK side might think she is a hostile and might shoot her at will. Those people are trained to shoot whoever steps behind the enemy lines into North Korea. His decision to run across the demarcation over to Seri is to probably shield her body in case his comrades fires a gun on her.

 

This is also why the NIS agents moved closer and pointed their guns at the NK side to protect the couple. It was a very tense moment where very little movement may start a blood bath. Her current health condition only comes in second.

 

When RJH yelled " do not run" to Seri, my heart dropped. Quite frankly, that scene was the best acted throughout the drama. SYJ and HB killed it with their acting.

 

Might I add, I loved the fact that the writers focused a lot on showing that yellow line separating NK and SK. It might seem trivial at first, but I found it so profound yet preposterous. Imagine being separated from the love of your life by literally a "yellow line." I thought that yellow line symbolized such deep political ramifications that applies to the real strife between NK and SK. It's brilliant how they managed to insert such political undertones so subtly.

  • Like 13
  • Love 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, alleram95 said:

@sheeeeee thanks for posting the IG clips :) 

 

This is my attempt to translate the last making video of Crash Landing on You. Apologize in advance for any mistakes or mis-translations I made. 

 

SR: Holding this (the flower vase) will make it looks pretty. Somehow it feels like...

PD: Like at the wedding scene

Caption: Two Ri couple small wedding

SR: Yeah, it has the similar feelings

 

Wait, are they referring to the wedding scene that was supposedly deleted from the final episode? I had some doubt that perhaps the 'secret' source saying there was a wedding scene wasn't true, but looks like SR and PD are actually talking about that here?

 

I find it funny how in this BTS HB just wants to stay away from all the lovey dovey physical moments. Doesn't want to do the jumping hug, just wants to stand and look at the Switz lake instead of hugging or kissing YJ... He's probably joking and teasing YJ and PD-nim, but I guess since this was filmed way earlier when production just started, he still needed sometime to get into the mood. Unlike our experienced YJ the melodrama queen who's always so bubbly and joking back with HB and PD-nim. This trio is so adorable :)) 

 

 

Here are all the heroes behind the camera who made CLOY happen. A big round of applause to all these hard working people. 

 

 

  • Like 13
  • Awesome 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Haha and did anyone of you guessed it right what other photos are taken in the studio? And why SR shed a tear that he had to pat her on the shoulder? 

 

and the goblin fans whom are unhappy should take it up with Nielsen and not with the drama! Nielsen cannot be wrong to give the overall rating for every kdrama there is and the peak each time determines what is a hot favourite scene per episode. This is vital info since peak advertising slots sell for more money. The fact is CLOY is number 1 for TVN for now 

  • Like 5
  • Love 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, alleram95 said:

@sheeeeee
 

During the past 2 months, I enjoyed the drama more because of the discussions of the plot in this thread. The gifs, the spoiler and every information that has been shared makes the waiting during the breaks and every weekend enjoyable. The first time I joined here was at page 19, while attempting to sub the highlight preview and probably this is my last post, my last translations for making scenes. (If there is another behind the scenes that might be released by tvn, do mention or tell me and I'll try my best to help when I have the time. )

 

 

Thank you every one for everything. See you on another thread ^_^

 


@alleram95  Thank you so much for all the translations that you had done on CLOY thread. Really appreciate your efforts as your translations for the previews and BTS had helped me to understand and know the previews and BTS. Hope to see you on another thread.

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am so happy about the ending but I’m not sure why I still feel so sad and unable to let go of RJH & SR.  For sure it has to do with moving on from the drama generally but I think it’s also attributed to how sorry I feel for these two.  With their story, I want to know they will get to live their lives without separation and actually get to grow old together, see each other’s grey hair, and raise children together.  It’s the day-to-day progression of life that I want them to enjoy while being by each other’s side, not just a few weeks out of the year. Their love was so strong in part due to the growth they helped each other experience as individuals, and it was all due to them having the benefit of being by each other’s sides.

 

I felt it more after seeing a clip yesterday of the end of episode 1 when RJH pulls SR to the side of his house gate and they look at each other - this was where it all started.  Their journey was so light hearted and then filled with turbulence and hardship and so much love, healing, and again, growth.  Re-living their experience from the start knowing what lies ahead is too much to handle without breaking down. It’s no wonder the writer kept inserting SR’s firm affirmations about re-doing everything all over again. Can you imagine SR doing it again from the beginning knowing what lies ahead?  She’ll cry so much I think :( 

 

I guess the wedding scene really would have helped me fill this void.  I am curious about the type of discussion RJH & SR had in their decision to get married.  What did they have to

do to make it work?  Surely since it’s likely this was filmed, there is a story for this, which we won’t be able to know about.  Huge sigh.

  • Like 3
  • Sad 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Idk whats wrong with netizenbuzz.

 

This site seems to hate Crash landing on you so much.

 

I remember they only translate bad news about crash landing on you ever since it started. But the good one never got translated.

 

The Pilot comment who slander The premise and first episode.

 

And then the controversial Political party

 

And then the Lee shin young Scandal ( which got denied but they never translate it again ) 

 

And the hyunbin accusation ( yet again only the bad news and never translate the Agency report ) 

 

And now the rating comparison with goblin which ofcourse bring the fan war between goblin diehard fans and CLOY fans. ( they are just picking bad news for cloy )

 

Here is my take on Goblin Vs CLOY

 

i am also a big fan of goblin and luckily had chance to go to Quebec back in december to see Goblin shooting place. One of the reason i want to go to quebec is because i watch goblin and see how beautiful it is. And yeah it is beautiful although i came at winter which had different vibe but still really good. 

 

The impact is there to help my decision to go to quebec ( it is really far from SEA ) and i could say thats Goblin Impact.

 

How about Cloy?

 

Looking at the switzerland scenery... damn i wish i got there again. This drama makes me want to explore swiss more. The last time i go to swiss was 10 years ago and as far as i remember i dont go to the place that cloy use to shoot but if i had another chance to go to swiss again i would try to find the place of shooting because it is so beautiful and would be really good to have a photo there. Thats also CLOY impact that can make people want to go to the shooting place.

 

For the twitter rant about goblin having more cultural impact than CLOY. I agree about that, it is respectable that Goblin cultural impact is higher than CLOY. BUT That doesnt mean the popularity of drama is not higher. 

 

Maybe it is not as popular in international ( except SEA because we all love cloy ) but in korea it is a hit drama that many people watch including the 21.683% rating that proves tons of viewers watching it. 

 

But you cant really compare goblin and Cloy.

 

One is a freaking Goblin who had all superpower and all the fantasy you want and the writter can write anything her want without thinking about the cultural aspect even if she want to make eun tak immortal, it wont be a big problem. 

 

How about CLOY? 

 

The premise is a sensitive issue that we all knew there are some political group who targeting the drama as their own propaganda. Also some people sceptical with the drama. 

 

But the drama prove otherwise with the growth and organic rising for the rating and viewership.

 

This one a single bad writting can make a huge impact into the cultural aspect for example. You cant just make RJH defect NK without bring a big problem. Or you couldnt just make se ri live in NK permanently without bringing problem. Or you couldnt just Revive GSJ magically like goblin ( although i would like to see him revived lol ) the writter need to write this part carefully and we got our swiss ending which make the most sense and Possible. 

 

It is Full Time Fantasy vs A bit fantasy but still looking at logic. Ofcourse people love fantasy more. Who dont want to have a boyfriend who had superpower and can teleport to anywhere and very rich? 

 

How about a Very rich NK soldier that you cant meet because of political situation?

 

Ofcourse people will choose goblin but it shows the big difference between the two dramas.

 

One is a full fantasy that make your mind blown

 

While the other had a little fantasy but still lookkng at the possibilty and logic of things happening in the drama with things close to reality as possible.

 

The impact alone is different. 

 

Cloy give us a glimpse of NK life as soldier,Rich people,Poor people,live in village,the military showdown,the execution, and many more. 

 

It shows the subtle difference between north and south and shows how big of difference the two country are. It really give u a better view of north vs south.

 

So overall, You guys shouldnt worry about goblin because this drama had it own charm that you guys couldnt get in other drama.

  • Like 19
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I feel like thousands of people across the globe are mourning today refusing to let go of RJH-SR.It is like I know them personally and they are very close to my heart.Their characters have really grown on us.I even dream about them now:bawling:.Omg this sepanx getting unbearable..My heart.

  • Like 8

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Man withdrawal is hard!

 

@L A thank you for providing your survey! Reminds me of all the cute moments we had in the show...

 

1. What is the most hilarious scene of our leads that you love?

I really like the first candle scene! When Seri almost hit him with the flower vase, and then  starts to cry, and JH's confused face as he takes the vase from her and gives her the candle to calm her down but she has a breakdown instead, because the candle needs to be scented...I just love this scene! I laughed and was touched and felt sorry for Seri at the same time. It's amazing and I rewatched it recently and it still makes me smile.

And can I have another one? When he stepped on the mine.. It was dangerous, but so hilarious, he claimed to be a professional in this field, and was acting like a peacock with his tail out and all of the sudden - stepped on the mine. And then she proceeded to nag him, wow, you said that you're a professional. :D And he was just trying to show off, I just loved their dynamic from the first minute they met. 

2. What is the most romantic/beautiful scene of our leads?

When they're saying goodbye at the border and he is crossing the wires for her. What a scene! Who knew that it could be so romantic - a soldier stepping over the wire, but here we are. I really liked that scene, and it felt special because we were also saying goodbye to our NK setting - Seri would never come back to this life again. And I felt kind of sad because...you  know, I liked their dynamic together there. I liked not the posh setting of SK, not when she was pouring money on him, but when simple kindness was breathtaking, when a bowl of noodles meant so much, when the scented candle was the most romantic thing a guy could possibly give... Anyways, I also like how this scene felt.

3. What is the saddest scene of our leads that broke your heart so badly? 

Their final goodbye. What a scene. The soldiers around them are pointing their guns, it really hit me hard that they are in fact star crossed lovers, and the yellow border said "Peace" but what is peaceful about this? The fact that he yells "Don't run'!", but she continues, so he has to step over once more, push the soldiers holding him away, and this time around, there is no cold mask on his face. JH finally, fully giving in to his feelings. And it's just heartbreaking. Seri running to him without care that she might be shot if she crosses the line - she is just so desperate to see him, to touch him and say their goodbye one more time. She doesn't care about her injury, she doesn't see anything else - just him. And she sees the handcuffs. And at first, he tries to tell her that everything is going to be fine, but eventually, he can't lie to her again - so corrects himself, "Even if it wasn't you were a gift in my life." And that is so true! He never ever showed so much emotion, felt so much love to a human being, and here he is. In handcuffs, caring for her. Their love is just on a completely different level. 
4. What is the hottest scene from our leads ( if there’s any :joy:)?

Hot is not the word I would use for this scene, but I think the hospital scene is very tender. When Seri is standing in the rain, and JH comes to her, their kiss is extremely tender. He kisses her and then makes sure it's ok, as if asking for her permission, and when she doesn't flinch he continues. And it's raining, and it's NK hospital, and it's so beautiful. I liked this kiss, because it showed slow, burning feeling. In his kiss, JH was asking for forgiveness,  he was showing his gratitude and making a promise. I liked that scene very much. If only we had a better cameraman :D 
5.What is your favorite line from our leads?

Oooh so many! Their dialogs are extremely witty and sweet and every line is delivered so well, I enjoy every line! But here are my favourite, I think

Seri's line: Even if I turn back time 100 times, If only I can do that, I would meet you again. I would get to know you and fall in love. I knew I would make that dangerous and sad choice.

Jeong Hyeok's line: Nothing will happen. But even if something happens, it's not your fault. I have no regrets. You came into my life like a gift. I am just grateful for that.

6. What is your favorite song?

The one that I still can't find :D  now I can say that it played in the finale!!! Honestly, just by listening to this ost I tear up. When it started playing, after days of nagging my fellow comrades and giving up, I hear it again! I couldn't believe my ears! When Seri comes to JH with the flowers and he is coming to her with the flowers, and this music....If before when I heard this song I always thought of the moment when Jeong Hyeok tells her that he will be able to protect her as long as she is within his sight, or when he finds out that he saved her on the bridge, but now....Now it's the song of our finale. I am so grateful that they included it. I was bawling when I heard it, there won't be any more moments to associate with this song. This is it. I just really took it in. The view, the flowers, the smiles of our leads. 

 

7. What is the most hilarious scene from supporting casts?

From the ahjummas - when they invited her to the birthday party. When she said nope, not going to the bp, and then showed up. All the actresses have such great chemistry! It was extremely entertaining to watch!

From the F5 - so many, hard to choose one...I really liked their shenanigans in South Korea! When they were describing to each other how they tried to find  JH. :D 

But also, when  Seri was crossing the mind field, and they are all like, what is wrong with this woman? Why couldn't she end up here tomorrow? :D  That was the peak of comedy for me! For comedic purposes, you can tell I just really like the first episode.

 

8. What is the most touching scene from supporting casts?

Oh when the ladies brought the food to their friend at night. Knowing the reality of NK, knowing, how hard and terrifying it must be, I am just grateful to the writer for the message that friends' love is just as important! That it can help you in the darkest times.

When Geum Eun Dong showed those heart fingers in the final, I lost it. Seeing this young kid in handcuffs, just desperately sending his final goodbye to his Sister, his love, I just...I will miss them so much T_T I am tearing up now just remembering this moment, how embarrassing! 

9.  What detail gives you the most satisfaction?

I liked the parrallels between the episodes, I liked how the episodes are echoing one another. For example, their meeting in Switzerland when Seri was paragliding and their hug in the finale resembles their first meeting in the woods of North Korea, when she fell descended from the tree. And even with the finger hearts, it played three times and all for the different reasons - the first time when Seri had nothing to give to JH, so she just got her heart out of the pocket. The second when she showed her gratitude to the boys and made JH oh so jealous! And the third one when it broke my heart because that's the last time she saw her dear boys. And there are many "nods" like that, which means the writer was constantly working and reviewing the scripts of the previous episodes. It's that attention to the detail that makes me want to come back to the previous episodes and remember these details as well. I think CLOY will be perfect to binge watch, because you remember all these details and get really excited when they come back.

 

10. What you wish you could have changed if you were the writer?

 

 if I had no political obligations, I would make them settle in South Korea. For good. I still insist, that the knowledge of Seri's and JH's characters would help the scene. I feel like nobody really had the deep knoweldge of the characters - including the director. I don't think that after everything they went through, JH would just stand there and wait for Seri to jump in his arms, I agree with Hyun Bin who wanted to either twist her, or catch her, or do something interesting. I'd rather have that.

I would also add some depth to Seo Dan's character. I would like her to do one good deed in this show. I feel like GSJ outshines her, and this is why he had to die. Which wouldn't be necessary if Dan was a strong character on her own. 

 

  • Like 10
  • Love 5
  • Awesome 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 minutes ago, eLizza said:

I feel like thousands of people across the globe are mourning today refusing to let go of RJH-SR.It is like I know them personally and they are very close to my heart.Their characters have really grown on us.I even dream about them now:bawling:.Omg this sepanx getting unbearable..My heart.

 

I feel you! :anguished: I am basically just waiting for Hyun Bin and SYJ to announce their real life wedding. Screw dating. With that chemistry, go straight to getting married and start making those twins. :relaxed:

  • Like 7
  • Sad 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I really love the Switzerland pictures the ones that were not aired. They look happy together and so much in love. Really wondering whether they are really just friends or really great actors? They had these pictures taken before intensive shooting in South Korea. But the sparks in their eyes are there! Amazing!!

 

I just remember Daddy Ri’s comment in the car: Are you crying? Haha. Hilarious! The way he asked and his expression like that make it funny. And RJH expression is undescribable afterwards!

Daddy Ri is really one important role for giving hilarious scenes and serious parts. I think I rarely see parents of RJH in other dramas. 

  • Like 7
  • LOL 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 minutes ago, c Cinc said:

 

I feel you! :anguished: I am basically just waiting for Hyun Bin and SYJ to announce their real life wedding. Screw dating. With that chemistry, go straight to getting married and start making those twins. :relaxed:

I can’t wait! I saw their picture of them grocery shopping. Was there any other omens capture showing them together in real life?!

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...