Quantcast
Jump to content
Go Seung Ji

[Drama 2018] Are You Human Too?, 너도 인간이니

Recommended Posts

15 minutes ago, butterflyeffect said:

There is a scene where JYH asks mom why she didn’t mention disaster mode to him and she replies that she definitely erased that programming before sending NS3 to Seoul. So unless it was a mishap, I think NS3 is capable of developing self-thinking aside from those programmed to him.  But we’ll have to wait and see I guess. I wish I could go home now so I can watch the full episode T-T...haha

The way he floating in the water is a very human thing to do like he was thinking, and getting wet does not mess with him it seems.

  • Like 8

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm pretty sure that they have filmed some interior scenes (Namshin's huge mansion) inside Manager Do's house! I recognized the entrance, the stairs and the double-height living room! :D Is it an homage to You Who Came From the Stars? :tongue:

 

I LOVED the bromance between N3 and the Secretary and N3's meeting with a new "chingu"... :heart: I remember seeing that vacuum cleaner in this teaser:
 


They are so cute! :D



I also liked the MMA fighting scene at the beginning: brutal, realistic and well-filmed!  

 


I'm on the director's side, on this matter. He humbly apologized, but I've nothing against that scene, personally. It was there for a reason.

Edited by triplem
With the exception of live cap, pls don’t post consecutively within an hour . Edit to add. TQ
  • Like 5
  • LOL 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, jerboa83 said:

I'm on the director's side, on this matter. He humbly apologized, but I've nothing against that scene, personally. It was there for a reason.

There was no reason for Seung Yeon to actually get hit, and multiple times at that. A few of you have brought up that the scene is there for a reason and I can understand that but like I said in an earlier post , the main problem most people had is with Seung Yeon getting hurt irl. Bad scenes happen in film/tv all the time but the key is people don’t get injured during filming. Anyway this would’ve happened months and months ago and Seung Yeon is ok so no point in stirring the pot now. Let’s drop this issue (like someone mentioned before) and just discuss the other aspects of the show :)

 

edit: regardless of how realistic it “needed to be”, it was a gratuitous depiction of violence towards women and obviously it didn’t sit right with a lot of people. They could’ve just alluded to it. Acting is acting, doesn’t mean violence actually needs to happen..and especially in this situation where they were just standing there...

Edited by butterflyeffect
  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, butterflyeffect said:

There was no reason for Seung Yeon to actually get hit, and multiple times at that. A few of you have brought up that the scene is there for a reason and I can understand that but like I said in an earlier post , the main problem most people had is with Seung Yeon getting hurt irl. Bad scenes happen in film/tv all the time but the key is people don’t get injured during filming. Anyway this would’ve happened months and months ago and Seung Yeon is ok so no point in stirring the pot now. Let’s drop this issue (like someone mentioned before) and just discuss the show :)


The resulting scene is very realistic: now I get why... :huh: Anyway, if you are hit multiple times you don't get only "ringing ears": if you are hit that way in that spot for real, it's like banging your head violently against a door (I've been practicing martial arts for many years, so I know it): that's why I think that Seo Kang Joon did his best to make it realistic without hurting her... She would be down with a concussion and a serious neck injury after one single take, otherwise.
I acted in a fighting scene to film a demonstrative mv, once: my opponent was a very good friend of mine and an expert martial artist, but we both took many hits during several takes from different angles, and we didn't complain since we wanted it to be as realistic as possible (even if we knew that only a few seconds were going to be included in the final clip).
Getting beaten up a little bit is a very common occurrence, when you film action scenes, especially the most intense and fast ones. The actors know it beforehand; they hid the marks on their bodies with makeup... It just takes being pushed on the ground or having to kneel on the floor to get bad bruises: dancers are covered in blue marks, not to mention martial artists, stuntmen/stuntwomen and also regular actors... There are also actors who decide to perform fighting sequences for real (or almost real): one famous example is the corridor scene (a single, very long shot with no cuts) from "Oldboy", starring Choi Min Shik and a bunch of actors who decided to fight for real for three days in a row, to get to that result. 

 

  • Like 6

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
23 hours ago, jerboa83 said:


The resulting scene is very realistic: now I get why... :huh: Anyway, if you are hit multiple times you don't get only "ringing ears": if you are hit that way in that spot for real, it's like banging your head violently against a door (I've been practicing martial arts for many years, so I know it): that's why I think that Seo Kang Joon did his best to make it realistic without hurting her... She would be down with a concussion and a serious neck injury after one single take, otherwise.
I've acted in a fighting scene to film a demonstrative mv, once: my opponent was a very good friend of mine and en expert martial artists, but we both took many hits during several takes from different angles, and we didn't complain since we wanted it to be as realistic as possible (even if we knew that only a few seconds were going to be included in the final clip).
Getting beaten up a little bit is a very common occurrence, when you film action scenes, especially the most intense and fast ones. The actors know it beforehand; they hid the marks on their bodies with makeup... It just takes being pushed on the ground or having to kneel on the floor to get bad bruises: dancers are covered in blue marks, not to mention martial artists, stuntmen/stuntwomen and also regular actors... There are also actors who decide to perform fighting sequences for real (or almost real): one famous example is the corridor scene (a single, very long shot with no cuts) from "Oldboy", starring Choi Min Shik and a bunch of actors who decided to fight for real for three days in a row, to get to that result. 

 

 

Think about it carefully: with that scene the director obtained exactly the same thing Namshin was planning to obtain by hitting Sobong in front of the cameras. A scandalized reaction by the netizens and an intense debate online. Quite an interesting social experiment...  

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was thinking about violance scene after read about reaction views. Maybe I am wrong but I think this not becomig big issue only becouse GSY get real hit. mostly, but no. I think that man slap woman created more problem. If this will be that critical scene if this will be only woman scene or man scene? Or if this would be fighting scene using material arts and actors get in real? I don't think so...knetz viewers also point that they feel uncomfortable watching this scene, so they feel that way before knowing that was not only acting. 

 

 

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've just seen ep 3 (or is it 5+6?) and Shin's mom is soooo cool. imo even though she knows NS3 isn't her real son, she still loves him all the same so I don't think she will throw him away. Or at least I hope she doesn't :'( lol. This drama is simultaneously predictable yet not, I love it.

I still find it really fascinating how SKJ makes all these different expressions just by changing his gaze. ie. when YH is looking at NS3 looking at the toy robots and it switches back to NS really quick, that subtle expression change is so good. Maybe too early, but imo he deserves an award for this role. Anyway, this episode was kind of slow for me ... probably since I spoilered myself, but I see it's going to pick up next episode so yay~ 

  • Like 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

120618 [You Are Human Too][Preview Ep 7] Romantic at the pool

P/s:The villa seems like the management of Do in the movie You Who Came From the Stars?

 

Edited by THT Chanel
  • Like 6

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey guys,

I finally caught up on all six 30-min episodes on Viu and I FREAKING LOVING IT! Worth the wait and the cast is definitely superb. Very intriguing characters, I must say. Plot is interesting and yes, I really can't wait to see the development between NS III and SB >> NS and SB.

 

And it does not help that I kept on thinking about GSY's character in Circle where she played an alien, thinking that she was human.

 

That is why this would be interesting how NS III will be the more likeable character as he becomes more "human" as time passes by. And Oh Yeah, I am liking the bromance too.

 

PS. SKJ really is a cutie pie and I love his eyes. GSY's too!

  • Like 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

can someone send some positive vibes here..  i am walking on eggshells here..

can someone see a happy ending without our robot getting hurt or die or transform into v4 ? 

 

he is pretty.. he has always been pretty.. but never felt these puppy vibes for him before this drama..and the cool vibes too in case of the human version

 

**************************

Also AAA+ to director for ep 7 preview for sticking close to law of gravity atleast in this one aspect..

 

when a man wearing a cap does a somersault in  a car chase.. the cap is bound to fall..

 

in normal universe, the cap would have stayed on the head.. pretty :)

  • Like 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, enigmatic_zephy said:

can someone see a happy ending without our robot getting hurt or die or transform into v4 ? 

Actually, transforming into version 4 is the most positive scenario I can think of right now. Seems highly unlikely that NSIII won't get hurt in the upcoming episodes. I'm more worried that at some point NS's mom will be forced to choose between her human son and NSIII. What she'll do in such a situation is scary, because she said so herself that she can do much worse for her son. It'll be especially tragic if NSIII will be able to feel emotions. 

  • Like 4
  • Sad 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Is Kang Seo Joon originally an idol? He’s honestly prettier than most of k-pop male and female idols :D

 

  • Like 1
  • LOL 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Whaa I have finally caught up with the latest episode and the thread :D 

 

About So Bong's behaviour. I certainly don't want to justify her actions but when we think  from her perspective I guess we may be able to understand her a little. Back then she lost a match because the referee was bribed. But it wasn't just  a failure. It probably shattered her dreams and the whole life. Her leg was injured and she was expelled from DFC. And it was all beacuse of money. In her opinion those with money have power and can ruin lives of people like her, who don't have much. She is sure that Nam Sin is one of those powerful jerks who think they can do anything they want. She acts like she has nothing to lose and that's why maybe she decided to live like that - "My life is ruined anyway. Might as well make money". I am not saying that things she has done so far are right. Because they aren't. But I am sure she is not a bad person. She is just angry with everybody and feels wronged. I think she will change soon. And  I bet that she won't tell  Seo Jong Gill anythig. She will be on Sin's side.

  • Like 7

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, nateko said:

Actually, transforming into version 4 is the most positive scenario I can think of right now. Seems highly unlikely that NSIII won't get hurt in the upcoming episodes. I'm more worried that at some point NS's mom will be forced to choose between her human son and NSIII. What she'll do in such a situation is scary, because she said so herself that she can do much worse for her son. It'll be especially tragic if NSIII will be able to feel emotions. 

i know..

 

anyone watched the good son!

 

i liked the ending though.. i know the ending was the whole point to the title of the movie.. but stilll its a decision you don't expect people to take

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, cadymcbronzie said:

PS. SKJ really is a cutie pie and I love his eyes. GSY's too!

Same. I think they really got the casting right for NS/NS3. The flicker in his eyes , the quick change in expression. Really good. This is my 3rd SKJ drama after CITT and Entourage. This is an excellent choice for career progression

@aisling Along with Gong  Myung , Lee Taehwan and 2 others, SKJ is part of an actor  group called 5urprise that is managed by Fantagio. They do sing but was set up to break into acting first  (unlike idol groups that started off singing before venturing into acting. )

--------------------

So I guessed right while live capping last  night that So Bang agreed to work for Seo as an undercover bodyguard was because she could not believe that Nam Shin would risk his life to save hers and that he seems to be behaving & speaking strangely. I liked how quickly NS3 is able to catch her lying. And I am wondering if he knew she was in the room , his vacuum pal may have transferred information to him.

Interesting as well , that he is showing some very human traits - despite mum removing the Disaster Mode, he acted out of his programmed mode. And he also told JYH that it is he who is the hero , not Nam Shin.  This is the need for self-worth or significance , a very basic but important human need. 

 

Completely enjoyed eps 3 . And oh bless my eyes...this Christmas i would like to have a NS3 for myself along with his handsome secretary. If mum is going to choose her own son over NS3 ( which would be logical) , then she should give NS3 to JYH , poor secretary here takes a lot of flak from the family. Loving their bromance & partnership

pHBREbE.pngpGCWwRs.png

  • Like 8

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Live cap

 

ns3 saw so bang leaving the house so he quickly took the car to follow him 

he realised that Mum may be in the hospital which is why he decided to go there

back to last night , he grab SB& she turns around shocked , she says who is that . He quickly said that does not even look like him.

 

 

  • Like 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

She let it slide & said some excuse why she was there. He checked & knew she lied.

JYH came & dismissed SB. Later he talk to NS3 asking why he was there etc. NS3 says he knows mum is here & ask why JYH lied. Anyway he told JYH that so Bang  saw the human Nam Shin 

 

So Bang report what she saw to Seo , but he can’t quite believe it 

  • Like 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




×
×
  • Create New...